Can Cats Eat Dog Food?

“If the food is safe for my dog, it’s safe for my cat” is a common misconception of pet owners. Different species have different dietary needs.

Feeding a cat food not intended for feline consumption can have unfavorable adverse effects and long-term consequences.

Learning how dog and cat food compare and the risks of feeding a cat dog food is essential for every caring owner.

Is Dog Food Safe for Cats?

“Is dog food safe for cats?” is a common question of people owning a dog and a curious feline. If a cat eats dog food, will it have any adverse effects? How much dog food can a cat eat safely?

The answer depends on the frequency of dog food consumption, serving size, and the cat’s underlying health conditions. Generally, dog food is safe for cats because it doesn’t contain toxic elements.

So, the owner has nothing to worry about if their cat steals a bit of food from the dog’s bowl.

However, cats can only eat dog food short-term. A cat’s nutritional needs are different from a dog’s, and an incorrect diet can have lasting negative consequences.

Furthermore, dog food typically consists of bulkier pieces that can be a choking hazard for cats used to swallow food without chewing it properly.

An important note is that dog food is only safe for healthy cats without underlying medical conditions that demand a special diet.

For example, even small amounts of dog food can be harmful to cats with diabetes due to a higher glycemic index.

Furthermore, cats, like humans, can have food allergies. Allergies to food intended for feline consumption, such as beef, are rare, but allergies to grains, vegetables, and other non-feline food are relatively common.

Cat Food vs. Dog Food Nutrition

To understand why cats shouldn’t eat dog food, we must learn about the difference in dog vs. cat nutritional needs. Cats are obligate carnivores; their bodies have evolved to digest large amounts of protein effectively.

A cat’s diet should contain no more than 20% carbohydrates and moderate amounts of fat. A cat’s stomach simply can’t digest large amounts of carbs, so frequently feeding cat veggies can hurt its gastroenteric health.

On the other hand, dogs are omnivores. Although their diet should mainly consist of protein, dogs can safely eat rice, veggies, and other foods high in carbohydrates. A dog’s stomach can digest nearly 100% of the carbs it consumes.

Because cats need more protein than dogs, they also have a higher amino acid and taurine requirement. If a cat isn’t getting enough amino acids and taurine, it may develop heart conditions and reproductive failure.

Another difference is the need for essential fatty acids. Dogs can synthesize essential fat acids, while cats can’t and must get them from food.

Cats also can’t produce active forms of vitamin A and niacin from food sources, while dogs can.

Due to these differences, cats and dogs need differently formulated foods. Dog food contains more carbohydrates and fewer fats, while cat food is richer in protein, vitamins, and minerals.

Cat Food vs. Dog Food Taste

Considering the difference in nutritional content, you may wonder – is there a difference in taste between dog and cat food? Perhaps, dog and cat food would taste equally horrible for humans.

However, each food type is designed to appeal to specific animal species. Dog food contains flavor undertones that cats cannot detect because they have fewer taste buds. For this reason, dog food rarely appeals to felines.

Since cats are carnivores, they are unable to detect the sweetness present in carbohydrates. Cats love fatty food, but dog food contains a minimal amount of fats, so it generally tastes blander.

On the other hand, cat food has a stronger odor and is usually juicier to appeal to felines, the pickiest of eaters. So, a dog being attracted to cat food is more likely than vice versa.

Cat Food vs. Dog Food Pellet Size

The pellet size is an apparent distinction between dog and cat food. Most dog food comes in larger pellets because dogs are significantly larger than cats. If the pellets were smaller, dogs would swallow them without chewing.

Because the feline mouth is so much smaller, cats can have difficulty chewing dog food and may choke.

However, there are exceptions – dogs of different breeds and sizes require different food, and a cat can safely eat food designed for small dog breeds.

Cat Food vs. Dog Food Price

Some owners wonder whether they could feed cats dog food because the latter is cheaper. Dog owners are indeed getting a larger food volume for a lower price, but the reason for such a difference isn’t always apparent for cat owners.

The explanation lies in the difference between dog and cat nutritional needs. Sources of carbohydrates, such as vegetables and grains, are typically cheaper than sources of protein, i.e., meat or fish.

Since cat food consists mainly of protein, its price is higher. Furthermore, cats have higher fatty acid, vitamin, and mineral requirements, so cat food manufacturers have to use more expensive ingredients.

Of course, there’s cheap cat food and expensive dog food. But within the same class, dog food is always cheaper because of the ingredients.

Feeding a cat with dog food to save some money may be tempting, but the owners should understand that such a decision can have long-term consequences, forcing them to spend significantly more on veterinary treatment.

Are There Nutritional Benefits to Feeding Cats Dog Food?

Dog food is safe for cats, but it isn’t healthy. The nutritional benefits of feeding cats dog food equal zero.

Dog food lacks taurine, fatty acids, vitamins, minerals, fats, and proteins essential for the correct functioning of a cat’s body.

A lack of protein in a cat’s body can lead to a reduction in muscle mass, developmental disorders in kittens, coat and skin abnormalities, and recurrent infectious diseases. Fat deficiency in cats mainly affects the skin, fur, and weight.

Vitamin A deficiency is the most common consequence of feeding a cat dog food. The first symptoms of vitamin A deficiency in cats are dull coat, weakness, and night blindness.

The deficiency of amino acids in cats, such as riboflavin and pantothenic acid, causes weight loss, alopecia, fatty liver, growth retardation, increased fibrosis, gastroenteric issues, and numerous other symptoms.

Dog food also contains too many carbs for cats. Excessive carb consumption in cats can lead to diabetes, heart problems, and obesity.

Apart from sugars, carbs contain fiber. Fiber is an essential element of a cat’s diet, but too much fiber can cause a gastroenteric upset, particularly diarrhea. In other words, feeding a cat dog food for extended periods has only drawbacks.

One may think that dog food is good for obese cats due to its lower fat content, but obese cats still need vitamins, fatty acids, and protein. Therefore, they should only eat specially formulated feline food.

On the same note, cat food isn’t healthy for dogs either, but it does have some nutritional benefits. Extra protein, vitamins, and microelements are unlikely to harm a dog unless it already has a surplus of specific elements.

However, the high fat content of cat food can lead to a weight increase in dogs, causing related medical conditions such as heart diseases, cancer, and hypertension.

The Cat’s Life Stage

The suitability of dog food for cats also depends on the cat’s life stage. Like humans, cats have different dietary needs at different ages or during specific periods, such as pregnancy.

Kittens have a higher protein requirement because it’s necessary for the correct muscle formation. They also need more fats, calcium, and fatty acids to ensure the proper development of the brain, bones, and other bodily systems.

Senior cats also need more protein than young cats to prevent muscle retardation and calcium to maintain bone health.

Pregnant cats need plenty of fats, essential acids, vitamins, and minerals for the proper development of kittens and lactation.

For this reason, dog food is ok for adult, healthy cats but not for kittens, senior cats, or pregnant felines.

Why Does My Cat Eat Dog Food?

Considering that dog food has a blander taste and is low in fats, a cat’s obsession with a dog’s bowl may seem odd. The most likely explanation for why a cat eats dog food is plan curiosity.

Most cats lose interest in dog food after trying it once. However, each cat’s taste preferences are unique, and a cat, as an individual, can be attracted to specific ingredients in the dog’s food.

The owner should consider which ingredients in the dog’s food appeal to the cat and provide it with a substitute. For example, if dog food contains carrots, a cat may appreciate boiled carrots as an occasional snack.

Sources