Best Dog Training Collar – Reviews & Buying Guide
Outlinist's team and our families are supported thanks to affiliate commissions that we may earn when you buy through links on our site. Read more

Best Dog Training Collar – Reviews & Buying Guide (December 2019)

Updated: November 13, 2019

Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar

After 50 hours spent researching the best dog training collars, we think Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar is the best for most people.

This choice is based on several criteria: brand, type, range, color, stimulation, dog weight, stimulation strength, battery type, charging time, adjustable fit, waterproof, ergonomic design, safe to use, remote display, and warranty, among other things.

 ProductPriceOverall RatingQualityEfficiencyAppearanceMaintenanceValue for Moneybrandtyperangecolorstimulationdog weightstimulation strengthbattery typecharging timeadjustable fitwaterproofergonomic designsafe to useremote displaywarranty
Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training CollarDogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training CollarCheck Price4.95.05.05.04.55.0DogtraRemote E-collar1320 yards (1200 meters)BlackShock / VibrationOver 35 lbs127 levelsLi-ion battery2 hoursYesYesYesYesLCD1 year
SportDOG X-Series Remote Dog Training CollarSportDOG X-Series Remote Dog Training CollarCheck Price4.85.05.04.54.55.0SportDOGRemote E-collar500 yards (460 meters)GreyShock / Vibration / BeepOver 8 lbs21 levelsLi-ion battery2 hoursYesYesYesYesNo display1 year
Pet Resolve Shock Remote Dog Training CollarPet Resolve Shock Remote Dog Training CollarCheck Price4.54.54.04.54.55.0Pet ResolveRemote E-collar1320 yards (1200 meters)BlueShock / Vibration / BeepOver 15 lbs10 levelsLi-ion battery2 hoursYesYesYesYesLCD2 years
PetSpy P620 Shock Beep Dog Training CollarPetSpy P620 Shock Beep Dog Training CollarCheck Price4.24.04.54.04.04.5PetSpyRemote E-collar650 yards (600 meters)BlackShock / Vibration / BeepBetween 10 and 120 lbs16 levelsLi-ion battery2 hoursYesYesYesYesLCD1 year
Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training CollarPet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training CollarCheck Price4.45.04.04.04.54.5Pet UnionRemote E-collar400 yards (365 meters)BlackShock / Vibration / BeepBetween 10 and 100 lbs100 levelsLi-ion battery2 hoursYesYesYesYesLCD1 year
Best Dog Training Collar

Are you ready to get the best dog training collar so that your furry friend can learn to be obedient and live a healthy life?

Training collars come in all types, so you’re sure to find something that works for you and your dog.

How do you train a dog well? There are lots of tools that you can use. For example, many people prefer to use a dog harness and dog leash (or dog retractable leash) to teach their dog how to walk well. It’s a lot safer than a dog collar, but you still need a collar for their dog tag. Don’t forget to take dog poop bags and the scooper with you!

Nervous dogs are a lot more likely to engage in difficult behaviors. Sometimes, you may need to use a dog muzzle when you’re going out around people. Or, you may want to put them in a dog carrier with their calming dog collar while you’re waiting at the vets or other places. If you’re not home, you can help your dog cope by using a two-way dog camera to talk to them.

Many people train their dogs to be good while they’re grooming them. Using a dog nail grinder or dog toothpaste and toothbrush can be stressful at first. So, if you aren’t using a dog brush or a dog dematting tool right then, you could use a dog recovery suit or anti-anxiety shirt to help them calm down. Just be sure to take it off before using dog conditioner and shampoo!

Agility is a great way to get your dog trained well. Use some dog food or dog treats and teach them how to use a dog agility tunnel and other fun tricks. Many dogs love using their energy to do these sorts of activities.

Investing in the best dog training collar can help steer your dog from negative behaviors and ensure that they learn well.

Selection Of The Best Dog Training Collars

Here are the best dog training collars for most people according to Outlinist:

Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar

Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar
(rated 4.9 / 5)
Quality
Efficiency
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

SportDOG X-Series Remote Dog Training Collar

SportDOG X-Series Remote Dog Training Collar
(rated 4.8 / 5)
Quality
Efficiency
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

Pet Resolve Shock Remote Dog Training Collar

Pet Resolve Shock Remote Dog Training Collar
(rated 4.5 / 5)
Quality
Efficiency
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

PetSpy P620 Shock Beep Dog Training Collar

PetSpy P620 Shock Beep Dog Training Collar
(rated 4.2 / 5)
Quality
Efficiency
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Collar

Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Collar
(rated 4.4 / 5)
Quality
Efficiency
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

Best Dog Training Collar Buying Guide

Pinch Style

Pinch collars, also referred to as “prong collars” do exactly what you think they do. If a dog starts to pull when they are wearing one of these collars, then they will feel the prongs poke at their neck.

While these work okay for light pullers, you want to be careful if you’re using them on especially strong dogs. If they pull too hard, the prongs could cause damage to their trachea and throat, which can be very harmful to them.

Choke Collars

Most people looking at a dog training collar for walking typically turn to choke collars so that they can teach their dog not to pull away from them. As the name suggests, these collars start to tighten as your dog pulls.

These are usually completely made from metal, so too much pulling could end up leaving marks on your dog’s throat. There is some debate as to whether or not these should be used, but if you’re an experienced dog owner, you’ll find that you can use them carefully.

Martingales

Many dog owners feel bad about making their dog wear an entirely metal collar, and because of that, the dog training collar martingale was invented. These are basically choke collars, but the only metal part is around the back of the dog’s neck, where the choke mechanism is.

Martingales are considered to be much safer, since they mostly feel (and look) like a traditional dog collar. They’re also much more comfortable for your dog.

Anti-Bark Options

If your problem is with barking, then none of the aforementioned collars are going to work as a training tool. Anti-bark collars use other methods in order to prevent a dog from barking.

Some anti-bark collars are going to emit a sound when the dog starts making noises above a particular volume. Others will spray citronella or another scent into your dog’s face using a similar mechanism. Or, it may just blow a puff of air into your dog’s face, surprising them and redirecting them from barking.

Invisible Fence Collars

Invisible fence collars typically use a noise, vibration, or shock system in order to discourage your dog from leaving a certain area. These are great for training dogs to stay in a particular area, because eventually, you should be able to take the batteries out and your dog will know the boundaries anyway.

You will need to install the fence barriers around the edge of your yard so that your dog has limits. You may also get one that uses radio waves to keep a dog within a particular range, as well.

Remote Training Collars

If you’re teaching your dog commands or you want to prevent them from leaving the yard or barking, a remote training collar can be helpful as well. These typically have something that looks similar to a TV remote, allowing you to control the collar from afar.

Nowadays, you can even get remote dog training collars with an app that allows you to connect the collar to your phone so that you can take care of problems as needed.

How Does the Battery Charge?

For anti-bark and remote options, there’s likely to be a battery powering everything and ensuring that the deterrent is going to work as expected.

Finding a dog training collar that’s rechargeable is your best option. Since these collars are so small to start with, you’d need to get something like a watch battery if you needed to change it. It’s much cheaper and easier to find something that has a charging station.

Head Halters

Head halters (also called head collars or head harnesses) are a newer innovation, but many large breed owners say that it’s a great option when they are trying to get their big dog to pull on their leashes less often.

These go around your dog’s snout and, when your dog pulls, it starts to close the snout slightly. This is meant to simulate how mother dogs will put their mouths around their puppies’ snouts when teaching them manners, and dogs respond to it quite positively.

Weather-Proof

Most of the time, your dog is going to be outdoors when using the training collar in question. You want to be sure that anything that’s metal isn’t going to rust, and that cloth options aren’t going to soak through and ruin the collar.

Look for options that have waterproofing on the outside, or that have nylon or other materials on there. This will help to weatherproof the collar and prevent any mechanisms from locking up or breaking entirely.

Your Dog’s Size

Bigger dogs need a lot more redirection and help when it comes to training, so you need to be certain that you get a collar that is the right size and that will actually be effective. You need to measure the diameter of their neck to ensure the former.

For effectiveness, you may need to look at the sizes that a particular collar is recommended for. As an example, you’ll need a bigger puff of air or a harder vibration to prevent a larger dog from barking or leaving the invisible fence area – otherwise, it’s just not going to do anything.

Range

How far does it work? Do you have to be right next to them in the yard if you’re using a remote, or do they need to be right next to your house for the electric fence signal to work?

If you’re using any type of electronic option for their collar, do some research into the distance from your phone or home within which it will work. You want to look for something that works 10 to 25 feet away – maybe even more – so that you can ensure that the training collar is going to be able to react to a dog that may not be right next to you.

Weight

This is something that your dog is going to need to be wearing on a regular basis, and heavy options may get uncomfortable and, in the worst cases, they could cause injury.

For example, a dog training collar for small dogs probably should be as lightweight as possible. The same goes for dogs with thin necks, like greyhounds. The smaller the neck, the more likely that your dog could get hurt if the collar is too heavy. Try to keep the weight to a couple of ounces and include the weight of any batteries as well.

Shocks

The best dog shock collar is one that fits your dog well without being uncomfortable. Remember, these are going to give your dog a little electric “pinch”, so you want them to be big enough and loose enough otherwise.

If a shock collar is used correctly – under supervision and at a very, very low voltage – they can help to get your dog’s attention and prevent them from doing whatever it is that sets the shock off. These are most commonly used for barking and invisible fences.

Vibration and Sound

For some dogs, a dog training collar that vibrates or makes some sort of noise is literally all that they need. If it makes a noise, it’s similar to a dog whistle – you likely can’t hear it at all.

These are more effective if you’re just trying to redirect your dog to something more positive as it catches their attention for a moment and then allows you to get their attention and redirect them. These collars don’t work on every dog, but they work perfectly on others.

Variable Settings

One of the most important things you need is the ability to adjust the vibration, shock, noise, or other deterrent that the collar is using. Variable settings allow you to deal with force, volume, and other such settings so that you can adjust as your dog becomes more obedient.

The best dog training collar will have multiple settings and will be easy to reset if you need to do so.

Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar
Our pick for the best dog training collar is: Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar. This choice was made after spending 39 hours researching dog training collars.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are training collars safe?

If the right person uses the collar and knows how to use it correctly, then training collars are perfectly safe. They become dangerous with ignorance or when cruelty is the reason behind the use.

If you feel like you aren’t going to be able to use a collar safely, or you’re concerned that you may do something to harm your dog while you’re using it, then avoid it.

Are training collars humane?

There are a lot of benefits of dog training collars, because they can help to give that little bit of negative consequence to your dog doing something that they shouldn’t.

Some collars, like shock collars, choke collars, and prong collars, can be very harmful physically and, sometimes, mentally. So, if you do use them, be sure that you are careful with how you use them and take note of how your dog acts with them.

How long can you keep them on?

Different dog training collar types can stay on for different periods of time. Some people will use invisible fence collars and keep them on all day; others will only use them when the dog goes outside.

In the case of choke and prong collars, you want to be sure that you take them off when your dog isn’t supervised, as the dog could accidentally harm themselves while they’re wearing it. Shock collars should be removed when you’re not around, as well.

Will a collar make a dog aggressive?

They can, if they are used the wrong way. While the majority of people will follow instructions and only use the training collars in appropriate contexts, there is a minority that will just do what they feel is best in order to try and control their pet.

Dog trainers like to say that there are no bad dogs, there are only bad owners – and that’s how it works with training collars. If you’re willing to learn how to do things in a positive manner, then they’re perfectly fine and you should never have to worry about your dog becoming aggressive.

How can I use it effectively?

Look online and talk to professional dog trainers in order to get tips for using a dog training collar correctly. Read the directions for the collar you’re using. Some basic tips include only using the collar during training sessions, using the variable settings properly, and not allowing others to use their training collar without your supervision.

The best dog training collar will only be effective if you decide to take the necessary steps so that you can use it correctly.

Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar
Our pick for the best dog training collar is: Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar. This choice was made after spending 39 hours researching dog training collars.

Sources

  1. The use of electronic collars for training domestic dogs, National Institutes of Health, Jun 29, 2012
  2. Collars, Choke Chains and Tying Dogs Outside, City of Minneapolis, Dec 13, 2018
  3. Shock collar, Wikipedia
  4. Characteristics of electronic training collars for dogs, National Institutes of Health, Mar 16, 2013
  5. Shock collars, Transportation Security Administration
  6. The Importance of the Proper Dog Training Collar, Illinois Aces, May 2, 2003
  7. Training dogs with help of the shock collar: short and long term behavioral effects, Washington University in St. Louis, Nov 5, 2017
  8. Dog training, Wikipedia
  9. Tricks and tips to keep dog training fun and interesting for both the handler and the dog, Michigan State University, Mar 12, 2013
  10. Risks of Shock Collars and Fences, Texas A&M Veterinary Medicine, Oct 18, 2007

Pin this article now!

Click this link to Check CYBER MONDAY Price »