Best Reel Mower – Reviews & Buying Guide
Outlinist's team and our families are supported thanks to affiliate commissions that we may earn when you buy through links on our site. Read more

Best Reel Mower – Reviews & Buying Guide (November 2019)

Updated: August 14, 2019

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

After 41 hours spent researching the best reel mowers, we think Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower is the best for most people.

This choice is based on several criteria: cutting width, dimensions, power, handle, cutting system, blades, blade material, height adjustment, height settings, wheels count, wheels, grass chute, grass catcher, weight, and warranty, among other things.

 ProductPriceOverall RatingEase of AssemblyManeuverabilityBalance & HandlingCut QualityValue for Moneycutting widthdimensionspowerhandlecutting systembladesblade materialheight adjustmentheight settingswheels countwheelsgrass chutegrass catcherweightwarranty
Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerCheck Price4.55.04.54.04.54.515-inch22.3 x 15.5 x 11 inSelf-propelledErgonomicStandard (contact)5-bladeAlloy steelFree1/2-in to 1-2/3-in28-1/4-inBackOptional19.6 lbs1 year
Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerCheck Price4.44.55.04.04.54.017-inch18 x 23.5 x 13.8 inSelf-propelledCushioned ergonomic gripStandard (contact)5-bladeAlloy steel5 positions1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in410-in front / 6-in rearFrontOptional41 lbs3 years
Fiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn MowerCheck Price4.34.04.04.54.54.518-inch24 x 23.5 x 14.2 inPushCushioned ergonomic gripStandard (contact)5-bladeAlloy steel7 positions1-in to 4-in46-in front / 10-in rearFront or backOptional51.7 lbs3 years
American Lawn Mower 1815-18 18-Inch Reel MowerAmerican Lawn Mower 1815-18 18-Inch Reel MowerCheck Price4.24.04.54.04.04.518-inch14 x 25 x 11 inSelf-propelledCushion gripStandard (contact)5-bladeAlloy steel7 positions1/2-in to 2-3/4-in210-in compositeBackOptional29 lbs2 years
Scotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel MowerScotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel MowerCheck Price4.34.54.04.04.54.520-inch18 x 28 x 10 inPushCushioned ergonomic gripStandard (contact)5-bladeAlloy steel9 positions1-in to 3-in410-in front / 6-in rearBackOptional34 lbs2 years
Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerEarthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerCheck Price4.44.04.55.04.54.016-inch23 x 27 x 47 inPushT-handleStandard (contact)7-bladeAlloy steel4 positions1/2-in to 2 1/2-in210-in compositeBackOptional26 lbs2 years
Greenworks 25072 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerGreenworks 25072 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerCheck Price4.34.04.04.04.55.020-inch18.11 x 28.35 x 11.02 inSelf-propelledCushion gripStandard (contact)5-bladeAlloy steel9 positions1-3/4-in to 2-3/4-in410-in front / 6-in rearBackIncluded31.8 lbs4 years
Great States 815-18 18-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerGreat States 815-18 18-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerCheck Price4.54.04.55.04.54.518-inch14 x 25 x 10.5 inSelf-propelledCushion gripStandard (contact)5-bladeAlloy steel7 positions1/2-in to 2-3/4-in210-in compositeBackOptional27 lbs2 years
American Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Push Reel MowerAmerican Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Push Reel MowerCheck Price4.64.04.54.55.05.014-inch24 x 20 42.5 inSelf-propelledT-handleStandard (contact)4-bladeAlloy steel2 positions1/2-in to 1-3/4-in28-1/2-in polymerBackOptional20 lbs1 year
Gardena 4025-U 15-Inch Electric Cordless Push Reel MowerGardena 4025-U 15-Inch Electric Cordless Push Reel MowerCheck Price4.85.04.55.04.55.015-inch22.3 x 15.8 x 15.6 inBattery-poweredErgonomicStandard (contact)5-bladeAlloy steelFree1/2-in to 1 1/2-in28-1/4-inBackIncluded35.4 lbs1 year
Best Reel Mower

Homeowners who are obsessed with a meticulously groomed lawn heartily recommend using the best reel mower.

Golf courses swear by them, sports “turf managers” create beautifully striped fields with them. But reel mowers are also practical and simple tools for the homeowner.

A push reel mower cuts differently and is gentler on your lawn than other mowers. Their scissor type action snips off grass cleanly while a gas powered or electric lawn mower’s rotary blades actually shred the top of the blades. Grass undergoes less stress and looks more attractive as a result.

Reel mowers (also called cylinder mowers) are considered green lawn mowers because they are so environmentally friendly. They don’t create emissions and no fuel, oil, or electricity is used. No noise pollution to deal with either, since there’s no engine!

Happily this adds up to lower costs. Cylinder mowers are inexpensive to purchase compared to other types, they last a long time and require very little maintenance. Grass that’s cut with their scissor action loses less water and isn’t as susceptible to disease, so you won’t be doing expensive additional watering or treating lawn problems.

Even the very best push reel mower won’t work for everyone, but they are especially good for small flat lawns without dips or hills.

Some would argue there is no best reel mower for large lawns. Others insist it’s practical if you don’t object to getting a workout. Adhere to a regular mowing schedule, since overly tall grass will simply bend over and the mower won’t cut it.

Selection Of The Best Reel Mowers

Here are the best reel mowers for most people according to Outlinist:

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower
(rated 4.5 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

Ready to go back to basics when it comes to mowing your lawn?

By getting a reel mower, you can ensure that your grass looks gorgeous each time it is mowed!

The beauty of a push reel mower is in its simplicity. There are no complicated machines, no electric or gas extensions, and there is no sound.

It is just you working hard in the yard, getting your lawn mowed.

And the reward at the end of your hard work is knowing that your yard will look pristine after every mow.

Information

Your grass will look so much healthier, because the Gardena uses blades that cut with a vertical shearing action.

The Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower is among the best push mowers that you can get. A classic product that blends in with its surroundings, performs excellently, and folds up for easy storage – it is a top of the line reel mower.

When you see one of these manual push mowers for the first time, you may be shocked at how thin and light they are. We are used to the big electric and gas lawn mowers. While those are easier to use, they also make a ton of noise, and they are not great for the grass.

With the best lightweight push mower on the market, you can still mow your lawn in quick time. And you get the benefits of silent operation, which means you can mow early in the morning without waking up your neighbors.

cutting width15-inch
dimensions22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in
powerSelf-propelled
handleErgonomic
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades5-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustmentFree
height settings1/2-in to 1-2/3-in
wheels count2
wheels8-1/4-in
grass chuteBack
grass catcherOptional
weight19.6 lbs
warranty1 year

While a manual powered mower may not be ideal for big yards, it is perfect if you have a small to mid-sized area of grass on your property. Your grass will look so much healthier, because the Gardena uses blades that cut with a vertical shearing action.

When your grass is sheared or snipped, the tips are greener and your lawn looks much healthier. Even the best rotary lawn mower will chop at the grass rather than gently snipping it. Instead of looking like it was cut to the bones, your grass will look as though it got the perfect trim that it needed.

There is a reason these mowers are used at sports fields and other locations, where the appearance of the grass is as important as its height.

Pros

Whether you are storing this in a corner of the garage, or you need to transport it to another location, being able to remove the handle makes the process a lot easier.

Rated as one of the best reel mowers last year, the Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower is a top machine in this category. Here are six of the most impressive features that we discovered for this particular Gardena model.

  • Quiet cutting experience: After years of using electric and gas lawn mowers, it is amazing to go back to a simple mower with blades that work silently. The experience is so quiet that you may not even notice the mower is working as your grass gets cut!
  • Cutting technique that involves minimal contact with the grass: There is a misconception that using manually-powered mowers will tire you out within ten minutes. With this lawn mower, that is not a problem. Its contact-free cutting technique means that it is very easy to push the mower through the grass, even if it is very thick.
  • Features a high quality cutting cylinder that produces extremely precise results: The cutting cylinder is made of quality steel and features a ground bottom blade. The result is a clean cut that is extremely precise. Your grass will look infinitely better after using this mower.
  • A removable handle means storage is a piece of cake: Whether you are storing this in a corner of the garage, or you need to transport it to another location, being able to remove the handle makes the process a lot easier. The mower can fit into the tightest of areas for storage purposes.
  • Features an unlimited cutting-height adjustment tool that is easy to use: When you start using this mower, you will notice that you can adjust the height of your cut in many different ways through a controller at the bottom of the mower.
  • Minimal maintenance and replacement part costs: Unless you use the mower roughly, there should be no reason for replacement parts in the near future. Unlike power mowers, which demand a lot of maintenance and costs, this mower will cost you cents to maintain each year.

Cons

Despite being one of the best push lawn mowers on sale right now, there are some issues with the Gardena 4023 model. Here are three cons that stood out as a result of our research.

  • With most lawns, you will need two passes to get all the grass: If you do not mind the extra work and time consumption, it is not an issue. But you will hardly ever get a good result if you only mow each swath of grass one time with this lawn mower.
  • The separate bag you can purchase is going to miss a lot of grass: One of the major issues with this mower is that you will get a lot of grass clippings lying around in your lawn, because the attachment bag is not as efficient as it could be. Cleaning up and bagging after mowing can be a chore.
  • Mowing a larger yard will take a long time: If you have a larger front or back yard, and you want every blade of grass to look perfect, it could easily take up a significant amount of time. While the end result is great, some may not appreciate having to put in that much effort.

Comparison

 

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width15-inch17-inch18-inch
dimensions22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in24 x 23.5 x 14.2 in
powerSelf-propelledSelf-propelledPush
handleErgonomicCushioned ergonomic gripCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades5-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustmentFree5 positions7 positions
height settings1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in1-in to 4-in
wheels count244
wheels8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear6-in front / 10-in rear
grass chuteBackFrontFront or back
grass catcherOptionalOptionalOptional
weight19.6 lbs41 lbs51.7 lbs
warranty1 year3 years3 years

Summary

It is an adjustment going from a powered mower to a reel one – but you will come to appreciate the simplicity.

If you are in the market for a simple and effective reel mower, the Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower should be near the top of your list. It does have some flaws, but the product’s good qualities far outweigh its shortcomings.

It is an adjustment going from a powered mower to a reel one – but you will come to appreciate the simplicity. The smooth action of the blades is better for your grass because of how they cut, they are whisper quiet to use, and they require next to no maintenance.

And you get the added bonus of having a good cardio workout each time you want to mow your yard! Why go to the gym when you can exercise and be productive at the same time?


Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower
(rated 4.4 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

A reel lawn mower is the kind your grandfather would have used, but modern technologies have improved cutting abilities.

A Fiskars reel mower is a prime example of how much old technologies can be improved upon.

Fiskars is a household name, and no wonder since the company has been around for centuries – literally.

Founded in the mid-1600s as an ironworks in a village in Finland, they have grown to be amongst the top global companies for lawn and garden supplies.

Fiskars reel mower parts, along with the rest of their products, are durable and worth purchase for longevity alone.

Information

The patented StaySharp technology allows blades to stay sharp as much as three times longer than the competition.

Fiskars has created one of the best reel mowers for Bermuda grass. This specific model will tackle even tough southern varieties – not only Bermuda, but also St. Augustine. The vast majority of authoritative push reel mower reviews agree that this model is up to the toughest jobs.

As a company, Fiskars has been around for over three hundred years. That is a significant amount of time to last and tells consumers they must be doing something right. Originally an ironworks, the company has worked its way up to become one of the leading consumer goods stores globally.

The Fiskars 6207 17-inch StaySharp Plus reel lawn mower is a quiet, durable mower that is significantly easier to push than heavier reel mowers. The clippings are shot forward, which means they won’t pile up on your feet and pants legs.

cutting width17-inch
dimensions18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerSelf-propelled
handleCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades5-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustment5 positions
height settings1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count4
wheels10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteFront
grass catcherOptional
weight41 lbs
warranty3 years

The blades on this mower are created to be both strong and long lasting. The patented StaySharp technology allows blades to stay sharp as much as three times longer than the competition. When they do finally get dull (if indeed, they ever do) the company sells sharpening kits so you don’t have to find a shop to sharpen the blades.

Manual reel mowers are traditionally better for your grass than gas-powered two stroke mowers. This is because gas mowers tear or rip the grass, which can cause a damaged lawn over time.

A reel mower, on the other hand, snips the grass not unlike the way a pair of scissors snips paper. This is gentler on the grass and allows for an overall healthier lawn.

Pros

It is a lightweight model that is easy to push around the yard. This is important, as mowers which are too heavy tend to place unnecessary strain on large muscle groups.

Reel push mowers are much more environmentally friendly than gas-powered mowers. There is no gas, no fumes, not even any electricity being used. It is possible for users to both get a better cut for their lawn and reduce their carbon footprint at the same time. What specific pros do you get with this Fiskars 6207 mower?

  • It offers a better cut: Since the blades on the mower snip at the grass like a pair of scissors versus ripping it apart, it produces a much better cut. The finished product is cleaner-looking, and grass is greener.
  • Clippings are shot forward: The grass clippings are discharged to the front of the mower, away from the user. Other models, on the other hand, discharge clippings to the back of the mower, which causes your feet to become covered and can be quite annoying.
  • Better mowing performance: Fiskars has patented an Inertia Drive Reel that allows for 75% more cutting power when compared to similar models. It also allows for the mower to handle things like sticks, rocks, or tough patches without stalling or jamming.
  • Strong, long-lasting blades: The blades are the most important part of any mower, and these are great. They are strong enough to cut even tough southern varieties of grass. They last a long time and stay sharp enough to get the job done.
  • Easy to push: It is a lightweight model that is easy to push around the yard. This is important, as mowers which are too heavy tend to place unnecessary strain on large muscle groups. This, in turn, can lead to injury. Thankfully, all this is avoided.
  • Quiet: This mower makes no noise other than a calming “snip, snip, snip” as it cuts your lawn. This benefits those who enjoy doing their lawn work early in the morning, as there is no loud roar like a two-stroke engine to bother the neighbors.

Cons

The major downside to reel mowers is that it takes a little more time and effort to finish the lawn than if you were to use a push or riding gas-powered mower. Continue reading below to find out cons specific to this Fiskars model.

  • The wheels could be better: While the rest of the mower holds up great, the wheels aren’t exceptionally sturdy. After extended use, they tend to wobble a little. Some reviews online say they even fall off.
  • Doesn’t tackle tall grass well: While this model does handle tough grass like Bermuda or St. Augustine better than most other mowers of this type, it doesn’t do great if the grass is too tall. If too tall, the grass tends to jam up the blades.
  • Not fast: A little extra time is needed to accomplish mowing your lawn when using this model, which may not work for those who do not have that additional time. The extra time is well worth it, however, for a better cut.

Comparison

 

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width17-inch15-inch18-inch
dimensions18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in24 x 23.5 x 14.2 in
powerSelf-propelledSelf-propelledPush
handleCushioned ergonomic gripErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades5-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustment5 positionsFree7 positions
height settings1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-in to 4-in
wheels count424
wheels10-in front / 6-in rear8-1/4-in6-in front / 10-in rear
grass chuteFrontBackFront or back
grass catcherOptionalOptionalOptional
weight41 lbs19.6 lbs51.7 lbs
warranty3 years1 year3 years

Summary

Besides being much eco-friendlier than its gas-powered counterparts, this reel mower is also very quiet.

The Fiskars 6207 17-inch StaySharp Plus reel lawn mower is a great purchase for customers who have a small area of grass to maintain and a little extra time to invest into the lawn. It is the perfect solution for people who have tough southern varieties of grass like Bermuda.

Besides being much eco-friendlier than its gas-powered counterparts, this reel mower is also very quiet. Instead of a loud roaring noise, it only makes a steady snipping sound as grass is cut. This works well for those who prefer to mow very early or very late so as not to be out at the hottest part of the day.

The mower is offered by a well-established company known for reliability and sturdy products. This adds a little extra assurance when purchasing. If a company has been successful for centuries, it must be doing something right.


Fiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn Mower
(rated 4.3 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

Hand pushed mowers offer a number of benefits that you’ll never get with any sort of powered mower. If you want the best lawn mower for a small yard, an old-style reel mower is the way to go.

Yes, you have to provide the power, but these cylinder mowers (the blades are fixed to a cylinder or “reel”) deliver a perfectly manicured lawn.

Manually powered reel-based mowers are perfect for getting a clean cut on a small yard, and a Fiskars reel lawn mower will rank near the top of any critic’s list.

Have you found the best reel mower this year?

This Fiskars 18-Inch model might just be the one you’re looking for. It is one of the best self-propelled lawn mowers this year.

Information

The reversible grass shoot is a heck of a feature. This allows you to keep grass clippings away from your feet.

The Fiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn Mower, being that it is a manual push mower, is extremely eco-friendly. Those who want to protect the environment but also get a great cut on their lawns should definitely consider a reel mower over an electric, and this one does the trick perfectly.

The InvertiaDrive reel works perfectly with any and every type of grass, so no matter how thick of a grain you are working with, this mower should be able to get the job done for you.

Thanks to the inset wheels, you can use the entire 18 inches to cover a lot of ground extremely quickly when compared to other mowers in this category. These wheels also make adjusting the height of your cut a whole lot easier than on other mowers.

cutting width18-inch
dimensions24 x 23.5 x 14.2 in
powerPush
handleCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades5-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustment7 positions
height settings1-in to 4-in
wheels count4
wheels6-in front / 10-in rear
grass chuteFront or back
grass catcherOptional
weight51.7 lbs
warranty3 years

The reversible grass shoot is a heck of a feature. This allows you to keep grass clippings away from your feet. You can either send the clippings forward, or behind the mower and down. This is something that you won’t find on many mowers like this.

The mower comes with a limited three year warranty, which is a much longer guarantee than you’ll get with a lot of other mowers. The machine is also durable, however, so you’ll probably never need to use the warranty, but it is nice to know that it’s there.

This is one of the most advanced reel mowers on the market, and it’s one that is certain to excite those who are passionate about their lawns.

Pros

The inset wheels on the front of the mower not only allow you to move the mower a whole lot easier, but they also make height adjustment a lot easier than any other mower in its class.

Reel mowers give you the perfect cut every time, eliminating jagged cuts that can lead to disease and bugs in your lawn. This particular mower offers a number of extra features that will certainly impress many people. Here are some of them.

  • Easier to push than most: The design of this mower gives you a little extra leverage, meaning that you can push it with ease. Many avoid hand mowers simply because they’re difficult to push, but few will ever have any issues with this one. Ease of use is a huge plus.
  • Cut any type of grass without a problem: The InertiaDrive reel can handle any type of grass. If you have a thicker grain of grass in your lawn, then this is the mower for you. You will glide through the thickest spots on your lawn with this machine.
  • Reversible grass shoot can avoid a mess: Getting your feet covered with grass is one of the huge downfalls of any hand push mower. Thankfully, you can adjust the grass chute to project the grass forward and away from your feet, which helps avoid a huge mess.
  • The inset wheels add so much: The inset wheels on the front of the mower not only allow you to move the mower a whole lot easier, but they also make height adjustment a lot easier than any other mower in its class. This makes everything a whole lot easier on you.
  • 18 inch blade width: 18 inches is nearly the widest you’re going to find a reel mower, and this provides you with that exact width. The inset wheels also allow you to avoid missing cuts on the ends, which means you won’t have to cover the same spot twice.
  • 3 year limited warranty: Very few mowers of this type will offer a warranty for this long. At three years, you know the manufacturer is confident that their product will hold up for quite some time. This gives you a bit of assurance that the product is great quality.

Cons

This Fiskars model may be one of the best push mowers out this year, but it is not flawless. There are a few things design-wise that definitely could have been done a little bit better. Here are some of the gripes that certain people might find with this mower.

  • Much heavier than most reel mowers: This mower weighs over fifty pounds, which is definitely at the higher range of push mowers. Although its heft helps with powering through tough grass, it makes it more difficult to store. Thankfully, the inset wheels mean it’s still easy to move around, even if it is a little heavy.
  • Have to purchase grass catcher separately: The adjustable chute is great, but if you want to attach a grass catcher, you’re going to have to spend a little more money. This mower does not come with a grass catcher; you are going to have to buy one separately.
  • Tight turns can be a bit tricky: Because of the design with the inset wheels, it can sometimes be a little bit difficult to make tight turns on a smaller lawn. While this is a small price to pay considering all the great features, it is something that people ought to consider before buying it.

Comparison

 

Fiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width18-inch15-inch17-inch
dimensions24 x 23.5 x 14.2 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerPushSelf-propelledSelf-propelled
handleCushioned ergonomic gripErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades5-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustment7 positionsFree5 positions
height settings1-in to 4-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count424
wheels6-in front / 10-in rear8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteFront or backBackFront
grass catcherOptionalOptionalOptional
weight51.7 lbs19.6 lbs41 lbs
warranty3 years1 year3 years

Summary

Its advanced design allows for an ease of use that has rarely been seen before. Because it can cut through any type of grass, it’s definitely recommended for those with thicker grains.

Overall, it’s difficult to have too many gripes with the Fiskars 18-Inch StaySharp Max Reel Lawn Mower. Its advanced design allows for an ease of use that has rarely been seen before. Because it can cut through any type of grass, it’s definitely recommended for those with thicker grains.

While the weight and difficulty around tight corners are downsides to this mower, they’re not deal-breakers for most. The overall benefits you’ll get make the cons worth it.

When it comes to reel mowers, it might not be possible to find a better mower on the market. There are just too many features with this one that you won’t find anywhere else. It is definitely recommended for those in the market.


American Lawn Mower 1815-18 18-Inch Reel Mower

American Lawn Mower 1815-18 18-Inch Reel Mower
(rated 4.2 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

Of course, they do take more effort than power mowers, but why not think of it as an easy workout?

Reel mowers get a bad reputation because they are not powerful machines, but the simplicity is what produces such a great cut of grass.

Instead of hacking at your grass and destroying it, a reel-type manual push mower will gently snip the tops off and leave you with a plush lawn.

Information

If you take the time to look through most any reel lawn mower comparison, you’ll find that this model holds its own against the competition.

The American Lawn Mower 1815-18 18-Inch Reel Mower is considered among the best self-propelled lawn mowers on the market. This model comes with five blades, which make it excellent for most residential use.

The 18-inch cutting width ensures that you will have no issues getting through the grass in your lawn, even if it is a bit thicker. And the 5 tempered allow steel blades will deliver a precise and exceptional cut every time.

Gas and electric mowers are fast and efficient, but they’re not good for the grass. They hack away at it leaving it prone to diseases and insect attacks. You will have none of those problems with this mower.

cutting width18-inch
dimensions14 x 25 x 11 in
powerSelf-propelled
handleCushion grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades5-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustment7 positions
height settings1/2-in to 2-3/4-in
wheels count2
wheels10-in composite
grass chuteBack
grass catcherOptional
weight29 lbs
warranty2 years

If you take the time to look through most any reel lawn mower comparison, you’ll find that this model holds its own against the competition. It offers you cutting height adjustments from 0.5 inches to 2.75 inches, and it is very easy to put together.

For those who are worried about collecting the clippings, it is possible to purchase a grass catcher attachment from the same company. It fits easily on the mower, and will catch most of the grass that is being cut while you are mowing.

This product comes with a two-year limited warranty, which means any faults with the manufacturing or parts will be covered. It is great to have this peace of mind when you are buying a mower, as you will know that the manufacturer can help you if there are problems with the product.

Pros

It has a thin, sturdy frame, so you can easily store it in the corner of your garage or storage room.

Most reel lawn mower reviews from last year and this year rate this American Lawn Mower 1815 model very highly, and we concur. Here are the six features of this mower that we found to be the most impressive.

  • High quality blades result in a better cut of grass: With tempered allow steel blades that feature a ball bearing reel design, you are getting the best with this mower. It will cut your grass like a barber snips your hair. It is a vast difference from the rough hacking of electric and gas mowers.
  • The nature of this mower means that maintenance is hardly required: There are no electrical or gas-operated parts to this mower. That simplicity means few things can go wrong, even if you are using it every day for years. And the blades will remain in good condition for a long time.
  • Lightweight and very easy to maneuver: Mowers that are hard to turn can make for a frustrating mowing experience. But this one is very easy to maneuver, even if you have a lot of narrow pathways of grass in your yard.
  • Easy to store: The mower weighs less than 30 pounds, which makes it very easy to pick up and move around. It has a thin, sturdy frame, so you can easily store it in the corner of your garage or storage room.
  • Flexible cutting height adjustments offer a lot of versatility: Being able to quickly adjust the cutting height anywhere from 0.5 to 2.75 inches means you have great flexibility in how tall or short you can keep your grass.
  • Mowing the lawn is whisper quiet: If you hate the noise made by electric and gas mowers, the whisper quiet operation of this mower will leave you very satisfied. It hardly makes a sound, which means you can use it early in the morning without waking anyone up!

Cons

This American Lawn Mower is an affordable and quality product with many good features. However, it does have some flaws. We have listed the three that stood out to us the most during our research.

  • Blades may need more frequent sharpening: The blades on this mower are designed to come in contact with the bed, which creates the scissor-like action that delivers such a good cut. The drawback of the design is that the constant slight touching can cause the edge of the blades to wear down more quickly that other mowers of this type.
  • Hilly areas can be a problem: Even though it is very light, you will have a harder time mowing hilly areas with this model. Some of the cuts will be uneven, even if you go over the same spot two or three times.
  • Longer or thicker grass will take more than one pass: If you let your grass grow for too long you will have make two or three runs through the same swath. It is designed to deliver a precise and gentle cut, but that means it will struggle going through thick or long grass patches.

Comparison

 

American Lawn Mower 1815-18 18-Inch Reel MowerAmerican Lawn Mower 1815-18 18-Inch Reel Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width18-inch15-inch17-inch
dimensions14 x 25 x 11 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerSelf-propelledSelf-propelledSelf-propelled
handleCushion gripErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades5-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustment7 positionsFree5 positions
height settings1/2-in to 2-3/4-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count224
wheels10-in composite8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBackBackFront
grass catcherOptionalOptionalOptional
weight29 lbs19.6 lbs41 lbs
warranty2 years1 year3 years

Summary

It is a simple reel mower, which will take some effort to use. But it cuts the grass so beautifully, especially if you use it on a regular basis to keep the grass at a manageable height.

If we were to give reel lawn mower ratings to each item we reviewed, this mower would score very high. The American Lawn Mower Company has done a great job in making a product that delivers on all that it promises.

You are not getting a power mower that is effortless to operate. It is a simple reel mower, which will take some effort to use. But it cuts the grass so beautifully, especially if you use it on a regular basis to keep the grass at a manageable height.

Among all the self-propelled push mowers available on the market, we believe this American Lawn Mower is a quality item that would make any homeowner happy with their purchase.


Scotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel Mower

Scotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel Mower
(rated 4.3 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

Everyone assumes that buying an electric or gas mower is the way to go.

While those lawn mowers will make for a quicker mowing experience, they are not as gentle on the grass as a classic push reel mower.

With a push reel lawn mower, you will find that your grass looks better after every single mow.

That is because these mowers are snipping the grass, instead of hacking at it with rotary blades like the electric and gas mowers.

In some ways, using a reel-type mower is about going back to basics. And there is nothing wrong with simplicity if it gets the job done!

Information

If anything goes wrong within two years, you will get replacement parts for free. It is great to have this peace of mind about a major purchase.

The Scotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel Mower is one of the best products in its category. This Scotts lawn mower offers exceptional value to people who are looking for an efficient and stress-free way of mowing the grass in their front and back yard.

With this Scotts mower, your grass will have the impeccably manicured look of a major league baseball field. You can easily adjust the cutting height, and you will find that you are getting very little resistance even if you are going through patches of thick grass.

Unlike the gas and electric mowers, you will not have to keep purchasing new Scotts reel mower parts because yours stopped working. This is the type of mower that will last you for years without needing much maintenance or upgrades.

cutting width20-inch
dimensions18 x 28 x 10 in
powerPush
handleCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades5-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustment9 positions
height settings1-in to 3-in
wheels count4
wheels10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBack
grass catcherOptional
weight34 lbs
warranty2 years

The Scotts 2000-20 has a 20-inch cutting width and features dual tracking wheels at 10 inches. It even comes with rugged radial tires, which will help with control and pushing through thicker parts of your lawn.

Buyers will also be happy to know they get a two-year warranty from the manufacturer when they purchase this mower. If anything goes wrong within two years, you will get replacement parts for free. It is great to have this peace of mind about a major purchase.

Featuring five heat-treated steel blades, this mower is going to give you an amazing mowing experience. The gentle slicing produced by the blades as they spin on the cylinder will result in healthier grass too.

Pros

The dual tracking wheels on this mower mean that maneuverability is not a problem. Even if you have narrow paths in your yard, this product will be easy to use.

The Scotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel Mower is a versatile and efficient self-propelled lawn mower. When we researched this model, we found the following six features that make it stand out from others of its type.

  • With quick snap height adjusters, changing the cutting height is easy: There are nine different grass heights that you can select, ranging from one to three inches. And it is easy to change the heights by using the quick snap height adjusters on the mower.
  • Two-year warranty means you are protected against malfunctioning parts: While this mower has a good reputation for build quality, faulty parts are always possible. With a two-year warranty, you will know that you are safe when buying this mower. Even if something goes wrong, your warranty will protect you.
  • The heat-treated steel blades are great for cutting all types of grass: No matter what type of grass grows in your yard, you will get good results with this mower. Its steel blades are designed in a way that results in the grass being clipped or snipped from the top. There is no hacking, which means your grass will remain healthy and vibrant after each mow.
  • With dual wheel tracking, this mower is so easy to move around: Some mowers have an issue where they can struggle in tight spaces. But the dual tracking wheels on this mower mean that maneuverability is not a problem. Even if you have narrow paths in your yard, this product will be easy to use.
  • Features a cushioned and ergonomic grip: Manually powered mower handles can be hard on your hands, but not so with this model. If you read push reel mower reviews to assess comfort of use, then you will be happy to know the ergonomic grip on this mower does its job very nicely. Mowing is a comfortable experience with this Scotts 2000-20 model.
  • Generous cutting width: The 20-inch mowing width of this model is at the top range for cylindrical push mowers. The average cutting width of these types of mowers is around 17 inches. This size can make a substantial difference in the amount of time it takes to finish the job.

Cons

Despite being an impressive product, this Scotts mower is not perfect. But is any product perfect? Here are three of the biggest flaws we found that potential buyers should know about.

  • It will struggle with taller grass: While the mower’s blades are designed to go through thicker grass, testing showed that it can have difficulty with grass heights over eight to nine inches. With this mower, it’s best to stick to a regular mowing schedule.
  • Does not work too great on uneven ground: Some users reported a poor experience when using this mower on uneven ground. That’s something to keep in mind if your yard has more than the usual ruts and bumps.
  • It can be tiring to use this mower in large spaces: If you have a bigger yard, you will find that using this mower takes quite a bit of effort. It is fun for a little while, but then you get tired of mowing. If you do not want a huge workout each time you mow the lawn, you may want to find another product.

Comparison

 

Scotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel MowerScotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width20-inch15-inch17-inch
dimensions18 x 28 x 10 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerPushSelf-propelledSelf-propelled
handleCushioned ergonomic gripErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades5-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustment9 positionsFree5 positions
height settings1-in to 3-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count424
wheels10-in front / 6-in rear8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBackBackFront
grass catcherOptionalOptionalOptional
weight34 lbs19.6 lbs41 lbs
warranty2 years1 year3 years

Summary

If you are seeking a no-fuss reel mower that will last for years and leave your grass looking healthy and vibrant, then you have found your ideal product.

The Scotts 2000-20 20-Inch Classic Push Reel Mower is a quality mower that will do a very good job for most homeowners who need to maintain a small lawn. With its generous cutting width and five steel blades that maintain their sharp edge, this mower definitely ranks high in its category.

If you are seeking a no-fuss reel mower that will last for years and leave your grass looking healthy and vibrant, then you have found your ideal product. It delivers a superb cut but, be aware that it can be less efficient with tall grass than other mowers.

There is nothing wrong with a simple machine if it gets the job done, and this mower does indeed get the job done right!


Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower

Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower
(rated 4.4 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

Reel mowers have been around since the early 1800s, but most have forgotten about them in our rush to use gas and electric powered machines.

Now we can return to the basics and achieve a much better cut on our grass.

With a reel mower, your grass will be much healthier which will make a significant difference in its appearance.

These mowers are easy to use, operate in a whisper quiet manner, and require little to no maintenance.

What you get with this type of mower is a stress and hassle-free experience. It is a simple machine designed to cut your grass in a superior and efficient way.

Information

You can easily fit the mower into a corner of your storage room or garage, and whip it out each time your grass needs cutting.

With the Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower, you are getting a sleek, classic and top of the line lawn mowing machine.

The Earthwise reel mower is among the best reel mowers this year, due to its combination of affordability and exceptional features. This 7-blade model delivers a 16 inch cutting width, while the cutting height can be adjusted from 0.5 to 2.5 inches.

One of the great things about this reel lawn mower is the versatility. You can choose between 5-blade and 7-blade models, depending on the type of grass that grows in your yard.

cutting width16-inch
dimensions23 x 27 x 47 in
powerPush
handleT-handle
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades7-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustment4 positions
height settings1/2-in to 2 1/2-in
wheels count2
wheels10-in composite
grass chuteBack
grass catcherOptional
weight26 lbs
warranty2 years

The 5-blade mowers are said to work best with taller and wetter grasses that are upright. For instance, if you have fescue, rye grass or bluegrass in your yard, you will want to get a 5-blade model. But if you have a bent grass, such as Bermuda, centipede or Zoysia, a 7-blade model will do the best job.

Thanks to its ultra-thin profile, this lawn mowing machine is so easy to store when you are not using it. You can easily fit the mower into a corner of your storage room or garage, and whip it out each time your grass needs cutting.

While it is tempting to go with an electric or gas mower, you will be amazed at how nicely this reel mower will cut your grass if you use it correctly.

Pros

Due to its simplicity and build quality, there is little to no reel lawn mower maintenance required for this machine.

The Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower is widely recognized as one of the top reel lawn mowers for sale. It delivers value, performance and versatility. Here are the top six features of the lawn mower that impressed us.

  • The five and seven-blade models work perfectly on different types of grass: While other mowers function decently on all types of grass, the five and seven-blade distinctions in the Earthwise mower ensure that you are getting superior performance on the type of grass that grows in your yard.
  • Significant cutting height adjustment in each model: Everyone has a preference for how they want their grass to look. Thanks to the 0.5 to 2.5 inch cutting height adjustment, you can fine tune your grass to the height that makes you happy.
  • Green frame makes for a very sleek and classy product: While you may not care about how your mower looks, you will be so impressed when you see this product for the first time. It manages to pack so many features into an elegantly simple and aesthetically pleasing design.
  • Requires almost no maintenance: Due to its simplicity and build quality, there is little to no reel lawn mower maintenance required for this machine. So long as you use it properly, you can continue to mow your grass for years without needing to spend money on replacement parts or upgrades.
  • Comes with a one or two-year warranty from the manufacturer: Depending on the model you purchase, you will be getting a one or two-year warranty from Earthwise for your mower. It is great to know that if something goes wrong with the item, you can get it replaced without cost in that time frame.
  • Snip the grass instead of hacking at it: Rotary power mowers are efficient and require little effort to use, but they hack away at grass. The result is ugly looking grass that is more vulnerable to insect attacks. With this mower, you are snipping at the grass in a gentle way.

Cons

While this Earthwise mower is among the best reel mowers available, there are a few issues with it. We uncovered three issues that you should know about before you choose which mower to buy.

  • Large yards will take a very long time to mow: If you have a yard that’s larger than one fifth of an acre, it will take you some time to complete your mowing job. And using a manual push mower requires some effort, so you should be prepared for a bit of a workout each time your grass needs cutting.
  • Catching grass is not as efficient as compared to electric or gas mowers: Even though you can purchase attachments to this mower to collect grass, those bags end up missing a lot more of the clippings as compared to electric and gas lawn mowers. If you do not mind some stray grass in your lawn, you will be fine. But if you do, you may want to find another mower.
  • It does not feature an easily removable handle: Unlike some other mowers in this category, this Earthwise mower does not feature an easily removable handle. It is not an issue if you keep your mower in the garage, but if you are putting it in a small storage room, you may have some space issues.

Comparison

 

Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerEarthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width16-inch15-inch17-inch
dimensions23 x 27 x 47 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerPushSelf-propelledSelf-propelled
handleT-handleErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades7-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustment4 positionsFree5 positions
height settings1/2-in to 2 1/2-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count224
wheels10-in composite8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBackBackFront
grass catcherOptionalOptionalOptional
weight26 lbs19.6 lbs41 lbs
warranty2 years1 year3 years

Summary

If you are convinced that this type of mower is best for your yard mowing, then you cannot go wrong by getting the Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower.

There will always be a reel lawn mower vs electric mower debate. While electric mowers are energy efficient, quiet and cut the grass rapidly, they do not deliver the same amazing aesthetic for your lawn as a reel mower.

The blades on a reel-type mower are much gentler on the grass, which helps in the long run. If you are convinced that this type of mower is best for your yard mowing, then you cannot go wrong by getting the Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower.

Earthwise have done a great job in producing a lawn mower that is easy to use, durable, precise in its cutting, and lightweight. It is one of the best self-propelled lawn mowers that you will ever use.


Greenworks 25072 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower

Greenworks 25072 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower
(rated 4.3 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

You usually can’t go wrong with a Greenworks push mower, as they produced some of the best reel mowers last year.

If you want a reel lawn mower with a grass catcher, you might end up paying a little bit extra, but it will likely be worth it.

This Greenworks cylinder mower comes with a reel lawn mower bag along with some other excellent features.

Information

If you want something without fumes that is easy to handle, then this just might be the mower that you’ve been looking for.

The Greenworks 25072 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower provides an excellent solution for those who don’t want to push around heavy gas or electric mowers. The 20 inch cutting path provides coverage that is comparable to a number of powered mowers.

Something that this mower includes that many mowers in this category do not is a 2-in-1 feature that allows you to either discharge or mulch. For a reel mower, this is a huge plus, as it provides you with an extra element of versatility that you might not be able to find anywhere else.

The mower allows you to easily adjust the height between 9 different positions. However, the lowest position is 1 3/4 inches, so it doesn’t quite give you as close of a cut as some other reel mowers that are out there.

cutting width20-inch
dimensions18.11 x 28.35 x 11.02 in
powerSelf-propelled
handleCushion grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades5-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustment9 positions
height settings1-3/4-in to 2-3/4-in
wheels count4
wheels10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBack
grass catcherIncluded
weight31.8 lbs
warranty4 years

The heightened front wheels and lowered back wheels make this mower extremely easy to push. The front wheels are ten inches and the back wheels are six inches. You’ll never struggle trying to get this mower up or down hills.

The fact that it comes with a grass catcher is an added plus. For most reel mowers, a grass catcher is something that you have to buy separately, so going with this mower can also save you a little bit of money.

If you want something without fumes that is easy to handle, then this just might be the mower that you’ve been looking for. It definitely provides a whole lot in a beautiful little package.

Pros

Few reel mowers provide you with an option for mulching, but this one does, which puts it ahead of the rest.

The advantages of this Greenworks mower are pretty obvious. As with any hand mower, you’ll get the perfect cut without the exhaust or fumes. However, you’ll also get these extra features that make this mower an excellent buy.

  • One of the widest cutting widths for a mower of its type: Generally, you’ll only find a 20 inch cutting width on larger power mowers. However, this mower provides you with exactly that width in a cylinder mower design, allowing you to cover a whole lot of ground.
  • Mulch or discharge your grass: Few reel mowers provide you with an option for mulching, but this one does, which puts it ahead of the rest. There is so much versatility in this design that you’ll be able to switch from job to job without any problems at all.
  • 9 different height positions to choose from: The more options you have, the better, and this mower gives you nine different options when it comes to your cut height. It’s also easy to adjust, so you’ll be able to switch heights in seconds instead of fiddling around with it for minutes at a time.
  • Larger front wheels for better maneuverability: Having the larger front wheels definitely help you to get around. This mower is so easy to push that a child should be able to handle it on most grass without any issues at all. There are few mowers that are easier to get around with than this one.
  • Grass catcher is included: Most reel mowers will require that you purchase a grass catcher separately. As a nice touch, this one comes with the grass catcher included. This is an added value that you will rarely find, and that’s why this is definitely a positive worth mentioning.
  • Relatively lightweight: At just over 30 pounds, this isn’t quite the lightest cylinder mower you’ll find, but it is on the lighter side of the spectrum. With everything that’s included in this mower, it’s pretty amazing that they were able to keep it well under 40 pounds, which makes it that much easier to push.

Cons

It’s still not perfect, unfortunately. There are few design flaws in this particular Greenworks mower, and anyone who’s interested in it should definitely take them into consideration before committing to a purchase. Here are a few of the flaws you might see.

  • Doesn’t quite go low enough for some jobs: Having 9 different positions makes this mower versatile, but because it only goes down to 1 3/4 inches, you won’t be able to use it for those jobs in which you need as close a cut as possible. This is definitely something to consider.
  • With longer grass, you might feel some resistance: While this mower generally moves pretty well, it has been known to struggle a little bit with longer, thicker grass. It’s usually not a problem, but if you do have a thick grain of grass or your grass has not been mowed in some time, there might be some difficulty.
  • Handle height is not adjustable: You can’t adjust the handle height, which can be a problem under certain circumstances. Generally, shorter people will be able to handle the mower just fine, but taller people might find themselves bending down quite a bit, which could cause back strain.

Comparison

 

Greenworks 25072 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerGreenworks 25072 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width20-inch15-inch17-inch
dimensions18.11 x 28.35 x 11.02 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerSelf-propelledSelf-propelledSelf-propelled
handleCushion gripErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades5-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustment9 positionsFree5 positions
height settings1-3/4-in to 2-3/4-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count424
wheels10-in front / 6-in rear8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBackBackFront
grass catcherIncludedOptionalOptional
weight31.8 lbs19.6 lbs41 lbs
warranty4 years1 year3 years

Summary

The fact that it comes with a grass catcher is an extra value that could end up saving you a little bit of money, as well.

If you’re looking for an all-in-one reel mower with extra versatility, the Greenworks 25072 20-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower just might be your best bet. With 9 height adjustments that are easy to set and a mulching option, this mower does just about anything you need it to.

The fact that it comes with a grass catcher is an extra value that could end up saving you a little bit of money, as well.

Although the cutting height doesn’t lower as much as some might like, and the handle height might cause some problems for taller people, it is a great mower when all is said and done. This is an excellent option for those looking to avoid powered mowers.


Great States 815-18 18-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower

Great States 815-18 18-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower
(rated 4.5 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

When looking for a lawn mower for sale, you usually can’t go wrong by choosing a reel mower. The best reel mower will give you the best cut.

While gas and electric mowers do allow you to cut with ease, they don’t always give you the best cut.

Power mowers have blades that move in a circular motion and chop off the top of the grass, as opposed to a cylinder based hand mower with vertical slicing blades.

The gentle snipping of reel-type mowers is much gentler than the harsh chopping of rotary blades.

For healthier grass and a peaceful mowing experience, this Great States reel mower is one that you should consider.

Information

Reel mowers provide clean snips of the grass every time, which means there’s never any tearing of the grass.

The Great States 815-18 18-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower provides excellent form and function. As with any Great States mower, height adjustment is easy. Not only that, but it also provides you with plenty of options between 1/2 to 2 3/4 inches.

Great states reel mower maintenance is always easy, especially when compared to other mowers of its type. The powder coated handle will last you a very long time and is unlikely to ever rust on you, which is definitely a plus.

Rotary mowers tend to cause problems with lawns because they’ll hack at the grass blades, removing fluids from the grass leaving it susceptible to disease and insects. Reel mowers, on the other hand, provide clean snips of the grass every time, which means there’s never any tearing of the grass.

cutting width18-inch
dimensions14 x 25 x 10.5 in
powerSelf-propelled
handleCushion grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades5-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustment7 positions
height settings1/2-in to 2-3/4-in
wheels count2
wheels10-in composite
grass chuteBack
grass catcherOptional
weight27 lbs
warranty2 years

With a width of 18 inches, this is one of the larger hand mowers around, meaning that you’ll be able to cover a whole lot of ground in a much smaller amount of time. The five blades also give you the perfect cut on even the thickest grass.

At only 27 pounds, it is also one of the lightest mowers of its type on the market. This makes it extremely easy to store with no problem at all. It’s also very easy to maneuver.

With all of this in one package, it’s no wonder that this is a mower that more and more people are choosing. It’s definitely a steal for anyone who’s decided on a reel lawn mower.

Pros

With an 18 inch width, you’ll be able to take care of a medium sized yard relatively quickly.

All hand mowers come with certain benefits that you’ll never be able to get with powered mowers. This Great States model provides a number of added benefits that even other reel mowers are unable to provide. Here’s a short list of the pros.

  • Spider 5 blades and a ball bearing reel: With five blades and a ball bearing reel that always moves smoothly, you couldn’t get a better cut if you were on your hands and knees with a pair of scissors. This is the perfect mower for anyone who is particular about their yard.
  • Easy height adjustment: It isn’t always easy to adjust the height of your cut with a mower. Thankfully, this isn’t a problem with this model. Easily adjust the height from 1/2 to 2 3/4 inches without any hassle whatsoever for excellent versatility. This is one of this mower’s top features.
  • 18 inch width: Particularly for a mower that you’ll be pushing, covering as much ground as possible is important. With an 18 inch width, you’ll be able to take care of a medium sized yard relatively quickly. Having such a large cutting width is definitely helpful.
  • Extremely lightweight design: At 27 pounds, this is one of the lightest mowers of any type you’ll find. Its lightweight design not only makes it easy to push, but also incredibly easy to store. At this weight, you don’t have to be a buffed out body-builder to finish the mowing task easily.
  • Powdered finish foam grip: The foam grip also makes this one of the most comfortable mowers you’ll ever use. Rather than dealing with a metal grip that will wear on your hands, this mower provides you with a nice soft cushion that you can hold for hours without any trouble.
  • Extremely durable design: The tempered allow steel reel and bed knife blade are both built extremely tough, which means that this particular mower will last you for years and years. With a mower built with this durable of a design, you won’t have to worry about it breaking on you any time soon.

Cons

Obviously, all products also have their cons. While this mower is excellent for those who want the perfect cut, it does come with some issues. Here is a list of the few problems that you might happen to have with this mower.

  • No way of catching grass: This mower does not come with a grass collector, so clippings will remain on the yard. Although this might be an issue for some, it should also be pointed out that a grass catcher isn’t something that comes with most mowers of this type.
  • Only cuts when pushed forward: The mower will not cut the grass while you are pulling it backwards. This means that you might have a difficult time in tight spaces, as you will have to be able to manage to get to the grass while pushing the mower instead of pulling it.
  • Issues with bumpy terrains on lowest height setting: Being able to cut down to a half-inch is great, but if you’re trying to do this on a bumpy terrain, you’ll want to raise the height a little bit. Unfortunately, it can be difficult to push over bumpy terrains on the lowest height setting.

Comparison

 

Great States 815-18 18-Inch Push Reel Lawn MowerGreat States 815-18 18-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width18-inch15-inch17-inch
dimensions14 x 25 x 10.5 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerSelf-propelledSelf-propelledSelf-propelled
handleCushion gripErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades5-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustment7 positionsFree5 positions
height settings1/2-in to 2-3/4-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count224
wheels10-in composite8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBackBackFront
grass catcherOptionalOptionalOptional
weight27 lbs19.6 lbs41 lbs
warranty2 years1 year3 years

Summary

With its easily adjusted height settings and lightweight yet durable design, there are going to be few hand mowers with its overall quality.

Without question, the Great States 815-18 18-Inch Push Reel Lawn Mower is one of the best reel mowers you’re going to find. With its easily adjusted height settings and lightweight yet durable design, there are going to be few hand mowers with its overall quality.

Although not being able to cut while pulling the mower is a bit of a drawback, it still provides you with some great plusses. There’s no grass catcher, but that’s not something that you always expect in a reel-type mower anyway.

All in all, this is an excellent reel mower, and it is definitely recommended for anyone who wants to get the best, shortest cut without having to struggle pushing around a heavy piece of equipment.


American Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Push Reel Mower

American Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Push Reel Mower
(rated 4.6 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

Avoiding powered mowers altogether is the best bet. You’d have to raise the height on a powered mower to avoid scalping, which means you won’t get the close cut you want.

There are many different reel mower brands, with reel lawn mower ratings often varying between them.

Is this American Lawn Mower 1204 model the best reel mower for Bermuda types of grass?

Information

The tempered alloy steel reel and bed knife blade is durable and easily sharpened. It also gives you scissor-like precision even on the tougher grass strains like Zoysia or Bermuda.

The American Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Push Reel Mower comes in a compact design, but that doesn’t mean that it doesn’t provide you with everything you need. As a self-propelled push mower, it can get the job done, particularly if you want to avoid scalping your grass while also getting a precision cut.

This reel lawn mower is self-propelled, but it’s also extremely light, so you’ll never have to worry about weight being an issue.

The tempered alloy steel reel and bed knife blade is durable and easily sharpened. It also gives you scissor-like precision even on the tougher grass strains like Zoysia or Bermuda. Imagine how good of a cut you could get if you cut your lawn with scissors. Well, this mower will just about do that for you with ease.

cutting width14-inch
dimensions24 x 20 42.5 in
powerSelf-propelled
handleT-handle
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades4-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustment2 positions
height settings1/2-in to 1-3/4-in
wheels count2
wheels8-1/2-in polymer
grass chuteBack
grass catcherOptional
weight20 lbs
warranty1 year

Because the cutting width is only 14 inches wide, this is not a mower that is recommended for larger lawns. With that said, the fact that it is so compact makes it a whole lot easier to store than most other mowers.

It uses a 4 blade reel, which will be just fine on most lawns. However, for lawns that are extremely thick or tall, this might not quite be as many blades as you need. Just keep in mind that this is best for smaller lawns with grass that is not extremely thick or high.

What it all comes down to is preference, and there is definitely a market for a mower like this if anyone who is looking for a compact design and precision cut.

Pros

The height adjustment is easy to use, and it goes as low as a half an inch, which would give you as low of a cut as any other mower on the market.

Yes, this American Lawn Mower is small, but some might be surprised at just how well it works on smaller lawns and tougher grass strains. Here are a few of the benefits that you’ll get with this mower when compared to certain other brands.

  • Extremely compact design makes storage easy: At only 14 inches wide, this mower is so small that you could store it just about anywhere without any problem. It’ll fit in a tight space whenever you need to put it away. You can also slide it under tables or benches without issue.
  • One of the lightest mowers around: This mower weighs in at just under 20 pounds, which means that it’s extremely easy to handle. In fact, a child would likely be able to push this mower around for hours without any trouble at all. One of the lightest mowers you’ll ever find.
  • Adjustable cutting height as low as 1/2 inch: Want to get an extremely low cut? That’s not a problem with this mower. The height adjustment is easy to use, and it goes as low as a half an inch, which would give you as low of a cut as any other mower on the market.
  • Rear grass deflection: Not only will this give you a precision cut, but the rear grass deflection keeps you from discharging grass all over the place. This means that clean-up is usually extremely easy. You’ll never have to worry about leaving cut grass all over the place.
  • Extremely low maintenance: Just a quick push and you’re on your way. Being able to cut grass precisely has never been easier. You’ll never have to worry about fumes or having to run to the gas station in order to fill up your mower. The blades are also easily sharpened.
  • Smaller wheel size than most: The compact design is the name of the game with this mower. Not only are the handle and blades small, but the wheels are only 8.5 inches, which gives you even more room for storage. Again, this is the perfect mower for small lawns at homes without much storage space.

Cons

Anything that comes in a package this small is going to have a few downsides. While the compact design of this American Lawn Mower 1204 model is great, there are some disadvantages that come with it, as well. Here are some reasons you might decide to buy a different mower.

  • Not ideal for larger yards: If you have a larger yard, the 14 inch width is going to mean that you’ll spend a lot more time pushing this mower around. The first big negative is the fact that it will not cover much ground for you.
  • Might jam up with taller grass or weeds: With only four blades, you’re likely to struggle with taller grass or weeds. If you cut your lawn regularly, this shouldn’t continue to be a problem. However, keep in mind that this mower won’t handle tall grass all that well.
  • Grass catcher sold separately: Most don’t like to leave cut grass on their lawn, and although this is certainly an affordable mower, you’re going to have to pay extra if you want a grass catcher so you can dispose of the grass after you’re done cutting.

Comparison

 

American Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Push Reel MowerAmerican Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Push Reel Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width14-inch15-inch17-inch
dimensions24 x 20 42.5 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerSelf-propelledSelf-propelledSelf-propelled
handleT-handleErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades4-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustment2 positionsFree5 positions
height settings1/2-in to 1-3/4-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count224
wheels8-1/2-in polymer8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBackBackFront
grass catcherOptionalOptionalOptional
weight20 lbs19.6 lbs41 lbs
warranty1 year1 year3 years

Summary

Those who want something that is extremely lightweight and easily stored away in a tight space are going to love this mower.

Those who want something that is extremely lightweight and easily stored away in a tight space are going to love the American Lawn Mower 1204-14 14-Inch Push Reel Mower. It definitely provides both of those things.

The small design does come at a price, however, so be sure to look for something a little bit bigger if you need to perform larger jobs. With that said, there is definitely a whole lot of value when it comes to this mower.

If you want a precision cut on tough grass varieties like Bermuda grass and don’t need to cover a lot of ground, then there are few mowers out there that will better fit your needs. Just consider both the pros and the cons before you make your purchase.


Gardena 4025-U 15-Inch Electric Cordless Push Reel Mower

Gardena 4025-U 15-Inch Electric Cordless Push Reel Mower
(rated 4.8 / 5)
Ease of Assembly
Maneuverability
Balance & Handling
Cut Quality
Value for Money
Check Price

Remember the old-fashioned push mowers with the cylindrical blades? An electric reel mower is the updated version of that old favorite.

When it comes to choosing a reel lawn mower vs gas powered for a small yard, it’s an easy choice.

A reel lawn mower provides numerous benefits over their gas-powered brethren for the property owner.

In reel lawn mower reviews, experts praise their superior cutting performance, cost-efficiency and the fact that they’re so much better for the environment.

When seeking a reel mower for your yard work, you should consider this Gardena mower that offers the benefits of traditional push models plus it’s battery powered.

Information

Exact height settings range from a little lower than 1/2 inch to about 1 5/8 inches high (12mm – 42mm).

Gardena is a German-based company founded over fifty years ago. They offer a complete line of gardening tools that are represented in more than 80 countries and are now a part of Husqvarna, a well-respected name in the lawn & garden equipment industry.

With the Gardena 4025-U 15-ich Electric Cordless push reel mower, you get the superior cut of a reel mower in a battery powered machine. With the power on, the job goes much faster but the mowing blades work just as well in manual mode which is handy when the battery runs out of juice.

An old-fashioned reel type mower delivers a superior cut because the blades rotate around a cylinder and gently snip the grass. Most power mowers chop the grass off with helicopter-like blades which are harder on the grass.

cutting width15-inch
dimensions22.3 x 15.8 x 15.6 in
powerBattery-powered
handleErgonomic
cutting systemStandard (contact)
blades5-blade
blade materialAlloy steel
height adjustmentFree
height settings1/2-in to 1 1/2-in
wheels count2
wheels8-1/4-in
grass chuteBack
grass catcherIncluded
weight35.4 lbs
warranty1 year

This best powered reel mower is lightweight and runs quietly so you can enjoy mowing when it’s convenient for you without worrying over bothering neighbors. It holds up well to moderate mowing requirements and slightly taller-than-usual grass heights.

The cutting height on this Gardena 4025 can be adjusted with a conveniently located controller switch. Exact height settings range from a little lower than 1/2 inch to about 1 5/8 inches high (12mm – 42mm). There are no preset heights – the switch enables you to choose any height within that range.

Gardena offers a twelve-month (or one year) warranty on parts. After the warranty period has passed, the company continues offering customer support through a free estimate on what is wrong and how much it will cost to fix.

Pros

Heights are adjusted through an ergonomically designed controller switch. Changing the heights does not require the use of tools or an extended amount of time.

Reel, cylinder-type mowers are favored for the professional cut they deliver, that’s why golf courses and ball parks use large models pulled by tractors. Because the Gardena 4025 is an electric powered reel mower, you get the superb cut of the cylinder blades plus power assistance to push it. What other benefits does it offer?

  • Can be used with or without battery: When or if the battery dies during use, there is no need to waste time recharging it. You can continue using the mower as a traditional push mower and consider the pushing to be an easy cardio workout.
  • No need to keep track battery time used: The LED battery level display takes away all uncertainty when it comes to how much longer the battery’s charge will last. The display is conveniently located directly in front of the user.
  • Easy cutting height adjustment: There are an extraordinary amount of possible cutting heights within the lowest 12mm setting to the 42mm top end. Heights are adjusted through an ergonomically designed controller switch. Changing the heights does not require the use of tools or an extended amount of time.
  • Lightweight: This Gardena reel mower has a very lightweight design which makes it easy to push around the yard. Without unnecessary weight, your back, legs, chest, and other large muscle groups are not put at elevated risks of sprains or strains.
  • Quiet: Reel mowers come with the key benefit of being quiet enough to mow your lawn at five a.m. without bothering your neighbors. Even with the electric option turned on, this model hums quietly as it cuts – much quieter than options powered by gas.
  • Tough enough to get the job done: Although lightweight, this model is exceptionally sturdy. It is tough enough to handle moderately difficult landscapes. This includes performing in high heats, dusty terrains, hilly landscapes, and grass neglected for slightly too long.

Cons

It does not matter how amazing a product is, a savvy customer knows there are always associated downsides. The key is in deciding which cons you can live with, and which you cannot. Continue reading to learn more about the cons associated with this Gardena mower.

  • Battery could last longer: The battery holds a charge for between half an hour and 45 minutes, depending on how rough the landscape is. This is fine for homeowners with small yards around 5,000 sq. ft., but may not be suitable for larger properties.
  • Collection bag isn’t great: The collection bag has a few flaws in the design that present a small hassle for users. For starters, it’s too small and doesn’t hold its shape well. It is also difficult to get the bag on and off the mower to empty clippings.
  • Mower tilts: Since the design is so lightweight, the mower tends to tilt backwards a bit when the collection bag gets close to being filled. This can be remedied by ensuring the bag is emptied often, although that may be too inconvenient for some.

Comparison

 

Gardena 4025-U 15-Inch Electric Cordless Push Reel MowerGardena 4025-U 15-Inch Electric Cordless Push Reel Mower

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn MowerGardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower

Fiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn MowerFiskars 6207 17-Inch StaySharp Plus Reel Lawn Mower

PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
cutting width15-inch15-inch17-inch
dimensions22.3 x 15.8 x 15.6 in22.3 x 15.5 x 11 in18 x 23.5 x 13.8 in
powerBattery-poweredSelf-propelledSelf-propelled
handleErgonomicErgonomicCushioned ergonomic grip
cutting systemStandard (contact)Standard (contact)Standard (contact)
blades5-blade5-blade5-blade
blade materialAlloy steelAlloy steelAlloy steel
height adjustmentFreeFree5 positions
height settings1/2-in to 1 1/2-in1/2-in to 1-2/3-in1-1/2-in to 3-1/2-in
wheels count224
wheels8-1/4-in8-1/4-in10-in front / 6-in rear
grass chuteBackBackFront
grass catcherIncludedOptionalOptional
weight35.4 lbs19.6 lbs41 lbs
warranty1 year1 year3 years

Summary

Customers love how it can be used without a battery if the charge does not last the length of the yard.

The Gardena 4025-U 15-inch Electric Cordless push reel mower is an overall good purchase for the customer with a small sized lawn with a wide variety of terrains. It offers a solid combination of a lightweight design and durability.

Customers love how it can be used without a battery if the charge does not last the length of the yard. People can continue mowing while waiting for another full charge, so no time is wasted when finishing the lawn.

Since it holds up to tough conditions like high heat, dust, and hills, this reel mower works well for any type of landscape. It is also quiet, making just a small humming noise as it works, so it can be used at any time of the day without bothering close neighbors.

Best Reel Mower Buying Guide

Four, five or seven cutting blades

Reel mowers typically come with four, five or seven blades. These blades rotate as you walk forward to pull the grass against a razor sharp edge, and cut the blades cleanly. The number of cutting blades should match the type of grass you’re growing (see below).

No matter how many blades you choose, look over the lawn before mowing to remove all but the smallest twigs or branches since they’ll dull or jam your push mower blades. You should also rake up leaves beforehand.

Matching the number of blades to your grass type

If you’re growing the finer, straight grasses like tall fescue, Kentucky bluegrass or perennial rye, then a 4 blade or 5 blade machine will perform well. Adjust the height of the mower for a cutting height of 2-3 inches or more.

A 7 blade model will work better for the thick-bladed low cut “bent” grasses such as zoysia, Bermuda, or St. Augustine. Since a cylinder mower is easier on the lawn, you can cut closely with the lowest recommended height for your grass.

Cutting system: Silent (non-contact) or standard (contact)

Two cutting systems are available on reel-type mowers. With either, as you propel the mower forward the blades pull the grass up to make contact with a cutting bar.

With the standard (contact) system, blades make contact with the cutting bar to be snipped. You’ll hear a clicking sound as you mow. The silent system is contact free so it is virtually silent; the blades come very close but miss the cutter bar. Both systems work equally well.

Height adjustment features

The height of the cut should not be compromised. Look for a mower that adjusts to the recommended height range for your grass type, and examine how the blade height is adjusted. Some mowers allow you to set the height easily with simple lever action, while others require unfastening bolts.

For low cut bent grasses, 1.5 to 2.5 inches high is optimal. Straight grasses shouldn’t be cut as low, so choose a mower that adjusts from 2 to 3 (or more) inches high.

Weight of the mower

Cylinder mower technology has improved and materials are better quality. Once bulky, now they’re often light enough to suit people of slight stature or those without a lot of strength. Even the heaviest machines are 50 pounds or less.

Heavier mowers make it harder to turn around, but just as with electric or gas lawn mowers, there are times it’s better to use a heavier model. If grass is extra thick or it’s a heavy-bladed grass variety, a heavier machine cuts more efficiently than a lightweight one. For finer grasses, lightweight models are fine.

Size of the cutting reel

There is some variation in the size of the cutting reels or cylinders found on reel mowers. A large diameter cylinder will generally have heavier blades too. This gives it more cutting power and is helpful if you have areas that include tougher grass or there are weeds in the mix.

A smaller diameter cylinder works just fine for a fairly weed free lawn, especially if your yard is small to medium size and flat like most typical suburban lawns.

Cutting width and overall size of mower

Most reel mowers have a cutting width of between 14 and 20 inches. The wider the cutting width of the mower, the more grass you’ll cut with each pass since it covers a wider swath of grass.

But wider mowers require more energy to push, so you’re not necessarily going to save time using a wider one. Consider any small areas you’ll need to mow too, such as fitting between shrubs, through narrow gates or between mulched bedding areas and sidewalks.

Wheel size and placement

Operating any push mower, whether it’s a gas model or an electric lawn mower, takes some stamina. With a reel-type mower, turning the wheels rotates the blades and creates resistance (known as torque) as the mower rolls across the lawn. Larger wheels can make it easier to push, especially on terrain that’s a bit rough.

If you have dips in your lawn, smaller wheels and smaller cutting width may prevent leaving un-mowed grass in those spots. Some newer models have wheels located in a way to reduce interference with cutting width, so you can mow closer to fences and obstacles.

Adjustable handle for comfort and operator height

Look for a handle that gives you a choice of multiple grip positions, along the top and the side of the handle. This makes it easier to maneuver turns, curved areas and small enclosed sections of lawn.

The handle should adjust to suit your height and the length of your arms. Make sure it feels sturdy too. Rubberized or other padding on the handle is more comfortable to grip. Wearing gloves if you are doing a large lawn can prevent hot spots or blisters.

To bag or not to bag

One of the pluses of a reel mower, as long as you’re keeping up with a regular mowing schedule, is that you’re trimming off small pieces of grass that can simply be left on the lawn to restore some of the nutrients in the soil.

Historically, cylinder mowers never had a grass catching bag to consider. In recent years some manufacturers have added it as an option to consider. As you’d expect, you’ll pay more for a cylinder mower that has attachments.

Blade sharpening and other maintenance

Blade sharpening isn’t needed very often. You could learn to do it yourself (check videos and directions online) or take it in to be serviced. Unlike any power mower, whether the lowest-end gas model or a high-end robotic lawn mower, reel mowers are so simple that most maintenance is quick and easy.

Water is fine to use for cleaning since there’s no engine to protect. Use a garden hose and scrub brush to remove any buildup of grass, dirt and debris. Use caution around the blades. A bit of grease and perhaps a wheel replacement once in a while, and that’s about it!

Reversible direction of grass chutes

Some models enable a change of direction that grass clippings fly out from the blades. Normally the chute directs the clippings backward and down, onto grass you just cut. An adjustable chute allows you to direct the clippings to eject forward onto grass that is still to be cut.

This accomplishes two things; clippings don’t land on your feet, and you get re-sliced pieces which are extra-small, perfect for mulching the lawn. Forward action isn’t recommended when grass is wet or dense as clumps ejected onto unmown grass may result in an uneven cut.

Maneuverability of the machine

When a push mower does not have good maneuverability, it becomes tiring to operate. Overall weight, size of wheels, and depth of wheel tread all combine to affect the physics of maneuverability.

Match your mower to the type of terrain you have. Extra-large wheels won’t allow the mower to stay firmly in contact with sunken areas, and you’ll end up mowing them two or three times to compensate. Lightweight machines can shift on slopes, making it difficult or unsafe to cut.

Stability of the machine

When ads mention classic lawn mowers for sale, this probably refers to reel mowers. They were once the only type available, but today’s cylinder mowers far surpass those – better engineering, sleeker lines, and they are made of modern materials.

Be sure you’re confident of the quality of the machine you choose and convinced of its stability. Is it well-balanced on turns, and does it fit into tight spots? Is the handle firmly attached to the base? Is the cylinder fitted well to the housing?

Balancing quality with budget

Cylinder mowers are more economical than nearly any other mower type, so you’ll be ahead financially from the outset. You get what you pay for, so it’s not a good decision to go with the cheapest options, but neither do you need the most expensive.

Plan on selecting a quality mower that gives your grass a good clean cut to keep it healthy and attractive. A first-rate reel-type mower may be the only mower you ever need to buy. Check out a few to determine the best reel mower for you.

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower
Our pick for the best reel mower is: Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower. This choice was made after spending 39 hours researching reel mowers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What features are most important?

Since reel or cylinder mowers are less expensive than other types of mowers, your budget will probably allow you to buy one that’s very good quality. Solid construction, adjustable cutting height, and matching the number of blades to the type of grass you’ll mow are the top priorities.

An adjustable grippy padded handlebar will ensure your personal comfort. Beyond that, reel mower reviews can help because it’s simply personal preference – narrow or wide cutting width, contact versus silent cutting system, lightweight or heavier model and more.

Is a reel mower better for the health of my lawn?

Yes, it often is better for your lawn. Since the grass is clipped cleanly like using a scissor, the grass suffers less stress than the tearing of the rotary blades found on almost all power mowers (including robotic lawn mowers), which makes it less prone to disease.

Heavier types of mowers such as a lawn tractor or a zero turn mower compact the soil. This also stresses the lawn and you will need to aerate the soil more often. Compact soil hampers root growth and will make your grass will grow thinner over time.

Can you save money using a reel mower instead of a gas mower?

Yes, fewer costs are associated with reel mowers. You won’t purchase gas or oil like gas lawn mowers require. You won’t be paying for electricity or batteries, and there is very little maintenance required, so yearly or twice-yearly trips for service are eliminated.

Reel mowers cost less than other types of mowers and last far longer. Though there’s an appeal with trendy gadgets like a robotic lawn mower, there are hidden costs – rechargeable batteries, anti-theft devices, perimeter wire and often an internet connection is needed to operate them.

Is a reel mower or an electric mower better for small lawns?

Either one suits small yards and neither takes up much room for storage. Unlike zero turn mowers or other riding mowers intended for large open acreage, reel mowers and electric models can maneuver the tighter areas which are typical of small yards.

An electric lawn mower will cost more, and you’ll need to either work around power extension cords or make sure to keep the battery charged. If you get a reel mower it’s likely to far outlast the electric one.

Why are most golf courses cut with a reel mower?

Golf courses generally have one or more people on staff whose sole job is to maintain beautiful, close trimmed and immaculate grass. Almost without exception they choose to use reel-type mowers to accomplish this.

Homeowners can enjoy the same benefit. Select a model that suits the type of grass you are growing along with the characteristics of your property, and neighbors will soon be asking the secret of your fabulous lawn. And you’ll be in better shape with the exercise you get while mowing!

Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower
Our pick for the best reel mower is: Gardena 4023 15-Inch Silent Push Reel Lawn Mower. This choice was made after spending 39 hours researching reel mowers.

Sources

  1. Mowing Tips by Department of Environmental Protection, Montgomery County Maryland
  2. Be A Grower not A Mower, National Service Center for Environmental Publications
  3. Lawn Mower Rebates, The City of Bowie, Maryland
  4. The UC Guide to Healthy Lawns: Reel Mowers, University of California Agriculture & Natural Resources
  5. Mowers and Mowing Safety, University of Minnesota
  6. Mowing Your Florida Lawn, University of Florida Gardening Solutions
  7. Mowing Tips, Texas A&M AgriLife Dallas Center
  8. Reel Mower, Wikipedia
  9. New Walk-Behind Lawnowers: Abusive Lab Test, Popular Mechanics, December 18, 2009
  10. Product Preview: Fiskars Momentum reel mower, Consumer Reports, February 18, 2010

Pin this article now!