Best Dog Plush Toy – Reviews & Buying Guide
Outlinist's team and our families are supported thanks to affiliate commissions that we may earn when you buy through links on our site. Read more

Best Dog Plush Toy – Reviews & Buying Guide (December 2019)

Updated: November 11, 2019

Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush Toy

After 44 hours spent researching the best dog plush toys, we think Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush Toy is the best for most people.

This choice is based on several criteria: brand, design, size (length), color, texture, material, lining, stuffing, seams, squeaker, chewable, non-toxic, washable, durable, and weight, among other things.

 ProductPriceOverall RatingQualityDurabilityAppearanceMaintenanceValue for Moneybranddesignsize (length)colortexturematerialliningstuffingseamssqueakerchewablenon-toxicwashabledurableweight
Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush ToyFluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush ToyCheck Price4.75.05.04.54.54.5Fluff & TuffFish14 inGreenSoftPlushMeshPolyester fiberDouble stitchedYesYesYesYesYes0.15 lbs
Pawaboo Stuffed Hedgehog Dog Plush ToyPawaboo Stuffed Hedgehog Dog Plush ToyCheck Price4.44.55.04.04.04.5PawabooHedgehog3.3 inBrownSoftSoft faux-furMesh (3 layers)PP cottonDouble stitchedYesYesYesYesYes0.09 lbs
Fluff & Tuff Football Dog Plush ToyFluff & Tuff Football Dog Plush ToyCheck Price4.85.05.04.54.55.0Fluff & TuffFootball8 inBrownSoftPlushMeshPolyester fiberDouble stitchedYesYesYesYesYes0.23 lbs
Multipet Duckworth Duck Large Dog Plush ToyMultipet Duckworth Duck Large Dog Plush ToyCheck Price4.45.04.04.04.54.5MultipetDuck14 inYellowSoftPlushMeshPolyester fiberDouble stitchedYesYesYesYesYes0.12 lbs
Ethical Pet Bungee Skinneeez Dog Plush ToyEthical Pet Bungee Skinneeez Dog Plush ToyCheck Price4.34.54.04.04.54.5SpotRacoon36 inGreySoftPlushMeshNoneDouble stitchedYesYesYesYesYes0.15 lbs
Best Dog Plush Toy

Entertaining your dog is easy when you have the best dog plush toy.

There’s no doubt Fido is over that old rubber ball, and tug-of-war is only fun for so long. So give man’s best friend something they’ll actually want to play with.

It’s hard to spoil your dog all the time. Sometimes you have to give them their dog flea treatment. Other times they need a dog muzzle, dog anxiety jacket, or worse, a dog cone.

Nonetheless, they love their rides in the dog bike trailer and dog bike carrier with you. Spoiling your dog even counts in the simplest ways. They don’t know the time you spend choosing their favorite food, or the fact that you clean up after them with your dog pooper scooper. But they do appreciate that when the weather is less than promising, you always equip them with their dog boots and dog raincoat.

As a good owner, you also never let them leave the house without their dog collar and dog tag. Of course, spoiling them doesn’t have to be as over the top as an automatic dog ball launcher, a simple dog retractable leash is one of the greatest luxuries for your dog.

One thing is for certain however, the only thing your dog loves more than their dog treats are their toys, and you love spoiling them. Any occasion is an excuse to buy a new dog chew toy or dog fetch toy, but that dog interactive toy was like Christmas.

So before you go out and buy that dog agility tunnel to spoil your canine companion, just remember how much they love their toys.

Selection Of The Best Dog Plush Toys

Here are the best dog plush toys for most people according to Outlinist:

Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush Toy

Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush Toy
(rated 4.7 / 5)
Quality
Durability
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

Pawaboo Stuffed Hedgehog Dog Plush Toy

Pawaboo Stuffed Hedgehog Dog Plush Toy
(rated 4.4 / 5)
Quality
Durability
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

Fluff & Tuff Football Dog Plush Toy

Fluff & Tuff Football Dog Plush Toy
(rated 4.8 / 5)
Quality
Durability
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

Multipet Duckworth Duck Large Dog Plush Toy

Multipet Duckworth Duck Large Dog Plush Toy
(rated 4.4 / 5)
Quality
Durability
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

Ethical Pet Bungee Skinneeez Dog Plush Toy

Ethical Pet Bungee Skinneeez Dog Plush Toy
(rated 4.3 / 5)
Quality
Durability
Appearance
Maintenance
Value for Money
Check Price

Best Dog Plush Toy Buying Guide

Reinforced Stitching

The best dog toys are the ones that can be played with over and over again. The only thing stopping your dog from endless play is how well the toy stands up to the workout.

Your dog’s plush toy will always start to rip first at the seams. So, if you want them to be able to play with their toy at least more than once, look for those with reinforced stitching. This stitching will be thicker, more durable, and therefore more likely to prevent rips and tears.

Multiple Layers of Fabric

While truly indestructible plush dog toys may not exist, one way to get close to indestructibility is with multiple layers of fabric. This way it’s like peeling an onion.

Once your pup has destroyed one layer, there’s yet another to be cuddled, chewed on, and thrown around. Having multiple layers of fabric increases the durability of the toy and the longevity, so that you’re not purchasing a new one once a week. Keep in mind that all that extra fabric might mean a little extra cleanup for you.

Squeaker vs. No Squeaker

The best plush dog toys with squeakers might be an oxymoron; they could be the best for your pup, but all that squeaking can make it the worst for you.

Nonetheless when choosing the right plush dog toy, you have to decide whether it needs a squeaker or not. In general, dog squeaky toys appeal to their instincts because the squeak sounds like captured prey. Squeakers can provide hours of entertainment for dogs that enjoy the sound, but be aware, not all dogs love them.

Pet Safe Material

Even if your dog isn’t an extreme chewer, their plush dog toy will still end up in their mouth, no doubt. In the mouth also means potentially in the stomach, since it is likely pieces of filling or fabric that fall off could be swallowed.

For these reasons, look for toys that are eco-friendly and non-toxic. Both the filling and outer fabric should be non-toxic so that your dog never gets sick from playing with their favorite toy.

Stuffing-Free

In all honesty, the stuffing is merely a setback; your dog really just wants to remove all the stuffing anyway. That’s why there are stuffing-free dog toys.

For one, stuffing just makes a mess, so save yourself some strife. Two, if you have a dog that is an insatiable chewer, dog plush toys without stuffing will actually last longer. Look for plush toys that are still soft on the outside, but are flat and filling free.

Velour

There are plush dog toys, and then there are cuddly plush dog toys. If your canine likes to cuddle, then you know which type of toy you need.

All plush toys are soft, but plush toys with velour are the softest. These are the toys that your pup will want to carry around, hold, and play with time and time again, because they may also double as a cuddle buddy. If your dog is not interested in cuddling, then you can skip the velour and shop typical plush toys.

Safety

Before you put their favorite toy in their dog backpack to carry to the park, consider how safe that toy really is. Plush toys are great because they are soft and inviting, but if they are fuzzy, shaggy, etc. you run the risk of creating a choking hazard for your dog.

If any of the fuzzy or shaggy pieces get torn off and swallowed, which they inevitably do, your dog could choke. Either you will need to avoid these toys altogether or supervise your pet while using them.

Size

Size always matters. X-large plush dog toys are not intended for small dogs, so be sure that the size of their toy is compatible with the size of the dog. If you have a small dog with a large plush toy, they might not be able to carry it around.

If you purchase a small plush toy for a large dog, they could choke on it. Small toys typically measure 4 to 5 inches, while large ones can be up to 20 inches. Know your dog and size the toy accordingly.

Durability

If your dog loves their toy, the last thing they want is to see it ripped and thrown away. That’s why you both need a toy with high durability.

When shopping, specifically look for stuffed dog toys for aggressive chewers. These will often have features such as reinforced stitching, multiple layers, hidden seams, and ripstop fabrics so that the toy is as tough as your dog’s bite. If you choose a toy that is not highly durable, you just might want to have a few backups on hand.

Design

Dog plush toys come in every shape and size, from dog plush football toys to yellow duck plush toys. Your dog may or may not have a preference, but if you think they do, go with it.

There’s nothing worse than buying a toy your dog doesn’t like, so keep in mind whether they prefer a round plush ball over a stuffed animal that can more easily chomp down own. If possible take your dog to pick their own toy, then you’ll always know which design they prefer.

Weight

What is inside your dog’s plush toy will determine its weight. Does it have a squeaker? Is it stuffed? Some dogs prefer heavier toys that will put up a little fight, others do not.

It is important to consider the weight of the toy because too light and your large dog might be easily disinterested; too heavy, and your small dog won’t be able to carry it around. The weight may also contribute to how durable and long-lasting the toy is.

Texture

Dog toy stuffed animals might feel different than dog toy plush balls. The difference is their texture. Plush animals are often soft and fuzzy, while plush balls are still soft, but with shorter “hair”. Other textures include shaggy with long threads, and extra-soft velour.

Know that your dog likes, but also consider which is safest. If the goal is to cuddle their new toy, choose a softer toy on the velour side. If they simply like to chew on soft things, plush balls might be nice, but try to avoid shaggy in which pieces could be swallowed and choked on.

Treat Compatibility

The only thing better than a great dog toy, is one that can also hold treats. It is common for owners to like to put treats inside, thus creating the best dog toys to keep them busy.

If you would like a plush dog toy that also stores treats, look for one with holes and compartments to store treats. Just remember after playing with “treat toys”, you’ll be the one who has to clean up the mess.

Battery powered

Your dog nail grinder isn’t the only thing with power; even plush dog toys can have a little power to them. These are the toys that may vibrate, shake, squeak, talk, chirp, etc., all on their own.

Battery powered plush toys are ideal for when you can’t directly play with your dog to entertain them (e.g., playing fetch), but the toy itself keeps them entertained. Toys with a battery pack in them however, also pose their own risks, such as if your dog is able to chew through to the battery pack.

Washable

When your dog loves a toy, they love them hard; dirt, saliva, mud, food, and all. There’s no doubt that their favorite toy has seen it all.

While you love how much your dog loves to play, what you don’t love is a mess in the house, or risk of your dog getting sick from germs on their toy. The solution? Look for a toy that is washable, especially machine washable. The best dog plush toy will be easy to keep clean and will make your pup think they’re getting a new toy over and over again.

Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush Toy
Our pick for the best dog plush toy is: Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush Toy. This choice was made after spending 39 hours researching dog plush toys.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is my dog’s toy safe?

Your dog’s toy should be safe, but the truth is, no one really regulates dog toy safety. Be proactive about keeping your dog safe with their toys by looking for options that have non-toxic filling and fabric.

You should consider if the toy could become a choking hazard for your dog. Lastly, there are several resources that list many dog toys which might contain chlorine, lead, and other harmful chemicals, so you know which ones not to buy.

Can my dog get sick from eating stuffing from their toy?

Yes, like an infant, your dog should be watched when playing with their toys. Hopefully they do not become sick from any harmful toxins in the material (since you were sure to avoid those), but getting sick could also be considered choking, or experiencing internal blockage.

If your dog swallows small pieces like stuffing, they could choke, or it could create an intestinal blockage, which often requires surgery. Warning signs include vomiting, not eating, and swelling. If you notice one or more of these symptoms, contact your veterinarian.

How do I stop my dog from destroying their toys?

Some dogs are just ultra-destructive or ultra-lovable. Either way, their toys end up getting the brunt of their love or abuse.

If you want to stop your dog from destroying their toys and teach them to be nice, the first thing it requires is supervision – always. Encourage your pup to play with a different toy once they start getting too aggressive. You may also reinforce positive playing behavior with treats and other snacks, until you are confident they will not destroy their favorite plush toy.

What is the best dog toy for avid chewers?

Some dogs just love to chew, but if chewing is turning into countless toys lost, and even more countless dollars spent on new ones, it might be time to consider a new toy.

Your dog may still enjoy a plush dog toy, but you’ll want to consider plush ones with these features instead: reinforced stitching, multiple layers, ripstop fabric, and hidden seams. This way your pup can still enjoy the softness of a plush toy.

Should my dog have their toy all the time?

Yes and no. If your dog has anxiety or trust issues, but they have a favorite toy that soothes them, then it’s a good idea to leave their toy out all the time.

You should also offer a variety of toys to your pet, but keep in mind that leaving toys out all of the time might limit their interaction with, well, you. Although you should be able to play with their toys together, by removing the toys occasionally, your dog can spend other time with you.

Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush Toy
Our pick for the best dog plush toy is: Fluff & Tuff Ruby Rainbow Trout Plush Toy. This choice was made after spending 39 hours researching dog plush toys.

Sources

Pin this article now!

Click this link to Check BLACK FRIDAY Price »